Desiderata of evidence for representation in neuroscience
Preprint
Abstract
This paper develops a systematic framework for the evidence neuroscientists use to establish whether a neural response represents a feature. Researchers try to establish that the neural response is (1) sensitive and (2) specific to the feature, (3) invariant to other features, and (4) functional, which means that it is used downstream in the brain. We formalize these desiderata in information-theoretic terms. This formalism allows us to precisely state the desiderata while unifying the different analysis methods used in neuroscience under one framework. We discuss how common methods such as correlational analyses, decoding and encoding models, representational similarity analysis, and tests of statistical dependence are used to evaluate the desiderata. In doing so, we provide a common terminology to researchers that helps to clarify disagreements, to compare and integrate results across studies and research groups, and to identify when evidence might be missing and when evidence for some representational conclusion is strong. We illustrate the framework with several canonical examples, including the representation of orientation, numerosity, faces, and spatial location. We end by discussing how the framework can be extended to cover models of the neural code, multi-stage models, and other domains.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 117 references indexed in Scilit:
- Learned interaction of visual and idiothetic cues in the control of place field orientationExperimental Brain Research, 1999
- Support-vector networksMachine Learning, 1995
- Analysis of fMRI Time-Series RevisitedNeuroImage, 1995
- Stimulus specific adaptation in excited but not in inhibited cells in inferotemporal cortex of MacaqueBrain Research, 1994
- Analysis of functional MRI time‐seriesHuman Brain Mapping, 1994
- Bits and brains: Information flow in the nervous systemPhysica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 1993
- Single unit activity in the rat hippocampus during a spatial memory taskExperimental Brain Research, 1987
- Responses of neurons in the inferior temporal cortex in short term and serial recognition memory tasksExperimental Brain Research, 1987
- The hippocampus as a spatial map. Preliminary evidence from unit activity in the freely-moving ratBrain Research, 1971
- A Mathematical Theory of CommunicationBell System Technical Journal, 1948