Urban neighborhoods in hot-dry climates experience severe heat stress during summer, increasing health risks and outdoor discomfort. This study evaluates the performance of different heat mitigation strategies in a representative neighborhood of Oujda, Morocco, using high-resolution microclimate simulations with the open-source urbanMicroclimateFoam solver, built on OpenFOAM. The model couples airflow, heat and moisture transport, and radiative exchanges to simulate pedestrian-level conditions over a five-day summer period. A parametric analysis is first conducted to compare the cooling effectiveness of increased surface albedo, irrigated grass, trees, and shading fabrics. In a second step, an urban microclimate “storyline” is developed to represent stages in the implementation process over time and to assess the progressive evolution of outdoor thermal comfort. Thermal comfort is evaluated using the Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI) at 2 m height. Results show that irrigated trees provide the greatest improvement, lowering UTCI by up to -4°C on average in their vicinity, followed by irrigated grass with up to -2°C reduction and shading fabrics reducing UTCI by -1.5°C, while high-albedo surfaces had negligible effects. The storyline analysis reveals that immediate shading deployment can locally reduce daily heat exposure by 30%, and that replacing artificial shade with trees increases and extends cooling benefits. In the long-term scenario, mature trees achieve up to 50% reduction in cumulative heat exposure compared with current conditions. Under drought stress, non-irrigated trees perform only slightly better than shading fabrics. These results provide quantitative insight into the efficiency and resource trade-offs of heat-mitigation strategies for arid urban environments.