The media of sociology: tight or loose translations?
- 15 June 2015
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 66 (2) , 345-372
Abstract
Sociologists have increasingly come to recognize that the discipline has unduly privileged textual representations, but efforts to incorporate visual and other media are still only in their beginning. This paper develops an analysis of the ways objects of knowledge are translated into other media, in order to understand the visual practices of sociology and to point out unused possibilities. I argue that the discourse on visual sociology, by assuming that photographs are less objective than text, is based on an asymmetric media‐determinism and on a misleading notion of objectivity. Instead, I suggest to analyse media with the concept of translations. I introduce several kinds of translations, most centrally the distinction between tight and loose ones. I show that many sciences, such as biology, focus on tight translations, using a variety of media and manipulating both research objects and representations. Sociology, in contrast, uses both tight and loose translations, but uses the latter only for texts. For visuals, sociology restricts itself to what I call ‘the documentary’: focusing on mechanical recording technologies without manipulating either the object of research or the representation. I conclude by discussing three rare examples of what is largely excluded in sociology: visual loose translations, visual tight translations based on non‐mechanical recording technologies, and visual tight translations based on mechanical recording technologies that include the manipulation of both object and representation.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- What is visualisation?Visual Studies, 2011
- Visual Sociology Reframed: An Analytical Synthesis and Discussion of Visual Methods in Social and Cultural ResearchSociological Methods & Research, 2010
- Contemporary Sociology and the Challenge of Descriptive AssemblageEuropean Journal of Social Theory, 2009
- "I didn't write the questions!" - Negotiating telephone-survey questions on birth timingDemographic Research, 2008
- Does image‐based field work have more to gain from extending or from rejecting scientific realism? An essay in reviewVisual Sociology, 2001
- Scientific Graphs and the Hierarchy of the Sciences:Social Studies of Science, 2000
- Ethno-Graphics and the Moving BodyMan, 1994
- Harvey Sacks's Primitive Natural ScienceTheory, Culture & Society, 1994
- Pictures of Nothing? Visual Construals in Social TheorySociological Theory, 1991
- The Rhetoric of Ethnographic HolismCultural Anthropology, 1988