Michael Guggenheim
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Michael Guggenheim has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Monika Krause
Goldsmiths College, United Kingdom
2 shared publications Bernd Kraeftner
Shared Inc. / Research Center for Shared Incompetence, Vienna, Austria
1 shared publicationJudith Kroell
Shared Inc. / Research Center for Shared Incompetence, Vienna, Austria
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 23 June 2017
- Published by sub\urban e.V. in sub\urban. zeitschrift für kritische stadtforschung
- Vol. 5 (1/2) , 147-152
Was macht die Planung? Theoretische Lockerungen mit ANT. Kommentar zu Lucius Burckhardts „Wer plant die Planung?“
Lucius Burckhardts Text „Wer plant die Planung“ ist zu Recht legendär. Schon der Titel ist ein genialer Wurf: Hinter dem Abstraktum ‚Planung‘ sind Akteure am Werk und an Akteure können Fragen gerichtet werden. Burckhardt war einer der ersten, der eine Expertenkritik formulierte und diese als ein Problem des Planungswissens, der Planungsmethoden und ‑theorie ausmachte und zugleich die Probleme der scheinbaren Lösung namens Partizipation ausmachte. Er betrieb Planungskritik in der Logik der Soziologie, jedoch ohne in einen banalen Soziologismus zu verfallen, der einfach böse Planer_innen guten Nutzer_innen gegenüberstellte.
- 23 June 2017
- Published by sub\urban e.V. in sub\urban. zeitschrift für kritische stadtforschung
- Vol. 5 (1/2) , 147-152
Open AccessWas macht die Planung? Theoretische Lockerungen mit ANT. Kommentar zu Lucius Burckhardts „Wer plant die Planung?“
Lucius Burckhardts Text „Wer plant die Planung“ ist zu Recht legendär. Schon der Titel ist ein genialer Wurf: Hinter dem Abstraktum ‚Planung‘ sind Akteure am Werk und an Akteure können Fragen gerichtet werden. Burckhardt war einer der ersten, der eine Expertenkritik formulierte und diese als ein Problem des Planungswissens, der Planungsmethoden und ‑theorie ausmachte und zugleich die Probleme der scheinbaren Lösung namens Partizipation ausmachte. Er betrieb Planungskritik in der Logik der Soziologie, jedoch ohne in einen banalen Soziologismus zu verfallen, der einfach böse Planer_innen guten Nutzer_innen gegenüberstellte.
- 15 June 2015
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 66 (2) , 345-372
The media of sociology: tight or loose translations?
Sociologists have increasingly come to recognize that the discipline has unduly privileged textual representations, but efforts to incorporate visual and other media are still only in their beginning. This paper develops an analysis of the ways objects of knowledge are translated into other media, in order to understand the visual practices of sociology and to point out unused possibilities. I argue that the discourse on visual sociology, by assuming that photographs are less objective than text, is based on an asymmetric media‐determinism and on a misleading notion of objectivity. Instead, I suggest to analyse media with the concept of translations. I introduce several kinds of translations, most centrally the distinction between tight and loose ones. I show that many sciences, such as biology, focus on tight translations, using a variety of media and manipulating both research objects and representations. Sociology, in contrast, uses both tight and loose translations, but uses the latter only for texts. For visuals, sociology restricts itself to what I call ‘the documentary’: focusing on mechanical recording technologies without manipulating either the object of research or the representation. I conclude by discussing three rare examples of what is largely excluded in sociology: visual loose translations, visual tight translations based on non‐mechanical recording technologies, and visual tight translations based on mechanical recording technologies that include the manipulation of both object and representation.
- 15 June 2015
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 66 (2) , 345-372
The media of sociology: tight or loose translations?
Sociologists have increasingly come to recognize that the discipline has unduly privileged textual representations, but efforts to incorporate visual and other media are still only in their beginning. This paper develops an analysis of the ways objects of knowledge are translated into other media, in order to understand the visual practices of sociology and to point out unused possibilities. I argue that the discourse on visual sociology, by assuming that photographs are less objective than text, is based on an asymmetric media‐determinism and on a misleading notion of objectivity. Instead, I suggest to analyse media with the concept of translations. I introduce several kinds of translations, most centrally the distinction between tight and loose ones. I show that many sciences, such as biology, focus on tight translations, using a variety of media and manipulating both research objects and representations. Sociology, in contrast, uses both tight and loose translations, but uses the latter only for texts. For visuals, sociology restricts itself to what I call ‘the documentary’: focusing on mechanical recording technologies without manipulating either the object of research or the representation. I conclude by discussing three rare examples of what is largely excluded in sociology: visual loose translations, visual tight translations based on non‐mechanical recording technologies, and visual tight translations based on mechanical recording technologies that include the manipulation of both object and representation.
- Open Access
- 6 January 2014
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Cultural Economy
- Vol. 7 (4) , 411-433
From Prototyping to Allotyping
The chapter analyses the invention and the form of the discourse on building conversion as one particular instance of redefining what a technology is and how it operates. I describe a shift from expert defined closure to lay based openness and tinkering as a shift from prototyping to allotyping: Since the early 1970s, change of use and building conversion have become a central and fashionable discourse among architects and architectural theorists. Before the 1970s, buildings were understood as technologies, as ‘society made durable’. The notion of building type was central to link a building to a given use. A bank was a bank because architects applied existing templates, prototypes, to turn a building into a bank. In the 1970s, suddenly buildings became flexible – discursively, since building conversion always existed: ‘Building type’ no longer was a meaningful link between a building and its use. A bank should not stay a bank, but become a hotel, a theatre or a flat, in short: an allotype. The chapter elucidate this central shift in thinking about buildings and reflects on the special case of allotyping buildings and how it continues to vex thinking about buildings.
- 6 January 2014
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Cultural Economy
- Vol. 7 (4) , 411-433
Open AccessFrom Prototyping to Allotyping
The chapter analyses the invention and the form of the discourse on building conversion as one particular instance of redefining what a technology is and how it operates. I describe a shift from expert defined closure to lay based openness and tinkering as a shift from prototyping to allotyping: Since the early 1970s, change of use and building conversion have become a central and fashionable discourse among architects and architectural theorists. Before the 1970s, buildings were understood as technologies, as ‘society made durable’. The notion of building type was central to link a building to a given use. A bank was a bank because architects applied existing templates, prototypes, to turn a building into a bank. In the 1970s, suddenly buildings became flexible – discursively, since building conversion always existed: ‘Building type’ no longer was a meaningful link between a building and its use. A bank should not stay a bank, but become a hotel, a theatre or a flat, in short: an allotype. The chapter elucidate this central shift in thinking about buildings and reflects on the special case of allotyping buildings and how it continues to vex thinking about buildings.
- 20 October 2013
- Published by Springer Nature in Qualitative Sociology
- Vol. 36 (4) , 445-464
Unifying and Decomposing Building Types: How to Analyze the Change of Use of Sacred Buildings
- 20 October 2013
- Published by Springer Nature in Qualitative Sociology
- Vol. 36 (4) , 445-464
Unifying and Decomposing Building Types: How to Analyze the Change of Use of Sacred Buildings
- 18 October 2013
- Published by University of Chicago Press in European Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 54 (2) , 187-210
The Couch as a Laboratory?
The debate about knowledge-production in sociology has pitted “internalist” accounts, which pay close attention to the places, practices, and tools of knowledge, against “externalist” accounts of institutions and fields. Using psychoanalysis as a case, this paper develops an approach that integrates these traditions by comparing the differentiation of places, tools and practices of knowledge production. The paper shows that, in a context in which other areas of practice increasingly differentiate research, diagnosis and treatment in spaces, tools, and professional roles, psychoanalysis invokes that differentiation rhetorically but refuses to differentiate its practice. Psychoanalysts insist on a specific setting – the couch and the psychoanalytic relationship – as central to all aspects of their knowledge-production but they do not adapt this space to pursue any of these purposes in their own right. This analysis explains some of the problems psychoanalysis has with its environment and the specific form divisions take within psychoanalysis. As an unusual case of non-differentiation, psychoanalysis highlights the role differentiation plays in other areas of knowledge-production.
- 18 October 2013
- Published by University of Chicago Press in European Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 54 (2) , 187-210
The Couch as a Laboratory?
The debate about knowledge-production in sociology has pitted “internalist” accounts, which pay close attention to the places, practices, and tools of knowledge, against “externalist” accounts of institutions and fields. Using psychoanalysis as a case, this paper develops an approach that integrates these traditions by comparing the differentiation of places, tools and practices of knowledge production. The paper shows that, in a context in which other areas of practice increasingly differentiate research, diagnosis and treatment in spaces, tools, and professional roles, psychoanalysis invokes that differentiation rhetorically but refuses to differentiate its practice. Psychoanalysts insist on a specific setting – the couch and the psychoanalytic relationship – as central to all aspects of their knowledge-production but they do not adapt this space to pursue any of these purposes in their own right. This analysis explains some of the problems psychoanalysis has with its environment and the specific form divisions take within psychoanalysis. As an unusual case of non-differentiation, psychoanalysis highlights the role differentiation plays in other areas of knowledge-production.
- 27 August 2013
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Distinktion: Journal of Social Theory
- Vol. 14 (3) , 284-304
‘I don't know whether I need a further level of disaster’: shifting media of sociology in the sandbox
If the media of research figure in the constitution of the sociological phenomenon, how is it possible to find out how they do so? 1 1 Many thanks to the team members Gerhard Ramsebner and Isabel Warner, who contributed to the execution of the project. View all notes Drawing on Garfinkel's idea of breaching experiments, we propose such an experiment to unearth the role of the media of sociology. The breaching experiment consists in an experimental setup to produce new disaster scenarios and accompanying forms of emergency provision. In the experiment, research subjects are asked to play in a sandbox with animal figures and other props to simulate disasters. The subjects are first asked to ‘build a world’, then to ‘turn the world upside down’, and finally to find an ‘emergency provision that would change the course of the disaster’. These plays are recorded with a purpose-built computer program and photographed and then transformed into fables and emergency provisions. The experiment breaks with three assumptions of media-use in sociology: First, sociologists use media exclusively for description, not creation of worlds. Second, sociologists do not tinker or produce their own recording technologies for specific research questions, but use existing ones, which define subdisciplines. Third, sociologists routinely rely on texts as the sole medium to represent the world.
- 27 August 2013
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Distinktion: Journal of Social Theory
- Vol. 14 (3) , 284-304
‘I don't know whether I need a further level of disaster’: shifting media of sociology in the sandbox
If the media of research figure in the constitution of the sociological phenomenon, how is it possible to find out how they do so? 1 1 Many thanks to the team members Gerhard Ramsebner and Isabel Warner, who contributed to the execution of the project. View all notes Drawing on Garfinkel's idea of breaching experiments, we propose such an experiment to unearth the role of the media of sociology. The breaching experiment consists in an experimental setup to produce new disaster scenarios and accompanying forms of emergency provision. In the experiment, research subjects are asked to play in a sandbox with animal figures and other props to simulate disasters. The subjects are first asked to ‘build a world’, then to ‘turn the world upside down’, and finally to find an ‘emergency provision that would change the course of the disaster’. These plays are recorded with a purpose-built computer program and photographed and then transformed into fables and emergency provisions. The experiment breaks with three assumptions of media-use in sociology: First, sociologists use media exclusively for description, not creation of worlds. Second, sociologists do not tinker or produce their own recording technologies for specific research questions, but use existing ones, which define subdisciplines. Third, sociologists routinely rely on texts as the sole medium to represent the world.
- Top Cited Papers
- 19 February 2012
- Published by SAGE Publications in History of the Human Sciences
- Vol. 25 (1) , 99-118
Laboratizing and de-laboratizing the world
How has sociology framed places of knowledge production and what is the specific power of the laboratory for this history? This article looks in three steps at how sociology and Science and Technology Studies (STS) have historically framed the world as laboratory. First, in early sociology, the laboratory was an important metaphor to conceive of sociology as a scientific enterprise. In the 1950s, the trend reversed and with the emergence of a ‘qualitative sociology’, sociology was seen in opposition to laboratory work. With the ascent of laboratory studies, the laboratory perspective was again applied to many fields, including sociology itself. Based on a definition of a laboratory as aiming at placeless knowledge and being inconsequential this article argues that the two waves of laboratorization were metaphorical and did not really turn the world into a laboratory. Instead, two alternative concepts, those of the unilatory and the locatory, are proposed to gain a more precise understanding of some of these metaphorical uses of the term ‘laboratory’.
- 19 February 2012
- Published by SAGE Publications in History of the Human Sciences
- Vol. 25 (1) , 99-118
Top Cited PapersLaboratizing and de-laboratizing the world
How has sociology framed places of knowledge production and what is the specific power of the laboratory for this history? This article looks in three steps at how sociology and Science and Technology Studies (STS) have historically framed the world as laboratory. First, in early sociology, the laboratory was an important metaphor to conceive of sociology as a scientific enterprise. In the 1950s, the trend reversed and with the emergence of a ‘qualitative sociology’, sociology was seen in opposition to laboratory work. With the ascent of laboratory studies, the laboratory perspective was again applied to many fields, including sociology itself. Based on a definition of a laboratory as aiming at placeless knowledge and being inconsequential this article argues that the two waves of laboratorization were metaphorical and did not really turn the world into a laboratory. Instead, two alternative concepts, those of the unilatory and the locatory, are proposed to gain a more precise understanding of some of these metaphorical uses of the term ‘laboratory’.