The Role of Moral Commitments in Moral Judgment
Open Access
- 24 February 2009
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Cognitive Science
- Vol. 33 (2) , 273-286
Abstract
Traditional approaches to moral psychology assumed that moral judgments resulted from the application of explicit commitments, such as those embodied in consequentialist or deontological philosophies. In contrast, recent work suggests that moral judgments often result from unconscious or emotional processes, with explicit commitments generated post hoc. This paper explores the intermediate position that moral commitments mediate moral judgments, but not through their explicit and consistent application in the course of judgment. An experiment with 336 participants finds that individuals vary in the extent to which their moral commitments are consequentialist or deontological, and that this variation is systematically but imperfectly related to the moral judgments elicited by trolley car problems. Consequentialist participants find action in trolley car scenarios more permissible than do deontologists, and only consequentialists moderate their judgments when scenarios that typically elicit different intuitions are presented side by side. The findings emphasize the need for a theory of moral reasoning that can accommodate both the associations and dissociations between moral commitments and moral judgments.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cognitive load selectively interferes with utilitarian moral judgmentCognition, 2008
- Throwing a Bomb on a Person Versus Throwing a Person on a BombPsychological Science, 2007
- Are Morally Motivated Decision Makers Insensitive to the Consequences of Their Choices?Psychological Science, 2007
- The intelligence of the moral intuitions: A comment on Haidt (2001).Psychological Review, 2003
- What we want to do versus what we think we should do: an empirical investigation of intrapersonal conflictJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2002
- An fMRI Investigation of Emotional Engagement in Moral JudgmentScience, 2001
- negotiating with Yourself and Losing: Making Decisions with Competing Internal PreferencesAcademy of Management Review, 1998
- Moralization and Becoming a Vegetarian: The Transformation of Preferences Into Values and the Recruitment of DisgustPsychological Science, 1997
- An empirical study of moral intuitions: Toward an evolutionary ethics.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1993
- The Trolley ProblemThe Yale Law Journal, 1985