The ethics of aggregation in cost-effectiveness analysis or, “on books, bookshelves, and budget impact”
Open Access
- 13 October 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Health Services
- Vol. 2, 889423
Abstract
In deciding how to allocate resources, healthcare priority-setters are increasingly paying attention to an intervention's budget impact alongside its cost-effectiveness. Some argue that approaches that use budget impact as a substantive consideration unfairly disadvantage individuals who belong to large patient groups. Others reject such claims of “numerical discrimination” on the grounds that consideration of the full budget impact of an intervention's adoption is necessary to properly estimate opportunity cost. This paper summarizes this debate and advances a new argument against modifying the cost-effectiveness threshold used for decision-making based on a technology's anticipated budget impact. In making this argument, the paper sets out how the apparent link between budget impact and opportunity cost is largely broken if the effects of a technology's adoption are disaggregated, while highlighting that the theoretical aggregation of effects during cost-effectiveness analysis likely only poorly reflects the operation of the health system in practice. As such, it identifies a need for healthcare priority-setters to be cognizant of the ethical implications associated with aggregating the effects of a technology's adoption for the purpose of decision-making. Throughout the paper, these arguments are illustrated with reference to a “bookshelf” analogy borrowed from previous work.Keywords
Funding Information
- Wellcome Trust
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Health technology prioritization: Which criteria for prioritizing new technologies and what are their relative weights?Health Policy, 2011
- The NICE Cost-Effectiveness ThresholdPharmacoEconomics, 2008
- Rights, responsibilities and NICE: a rejoinder to HarrisJournal of Medical Ethics, 2007
- Wickedness or folly? The ethics of NICE’s decisionsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2006
- NICE is not cost effectiveJournal of Medical Ethics, 2006
- Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs): The silence of the lambdaSocial Science & Medicine, 2006
- NICE discriminationJournal of Medical Ethics, 2005
- Nice and not so niceJournal of Medical Ethics, 2005
- It’s not NICE to discriminateJournal of Medical Ethics, 2005
- The Decision Rules of Cost-Effectiveness AnalysisPharmacoEconomics, 1996