Should Human Capital Development Programs be Mandatory or Voluntary? Evidence from a Field Experiment on Mentorship
Top Cited Papers
- 1 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 72 (6) , 4610-4632
Abstract
In a field experiment, we find that a mandatory mentorship program raises worker productivity, whereas a voluntary version of the program does not. A significant reason why the mandatory program results in larger gains is that the lowest-productivity employees do not participate when the program is voluntary despite their having the greatest treatment benefits. A nationally representative survey of U.S. workers shows wide variation in human capital development program participation, suggesting that understanding self-selection is important for firms’ returns on these programs across a variety of settings. Our findings have implications for resource allocation, experimental design, productivity dispersion, and inequality. This paper was accepted by Maria Guadalupe, business strategy. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2024.07524 .Keywords
This publication has 87 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effects of a Workplace Wellness Program on Employee Health, Health Beliefs, and Medical UseJAMA Internal Medicine, 2020
- Who's the Boss? The effect of strong leadership on employee turnoverJournal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2019
- When does advice impact startup performance?Strategic Management Journal, 2018
- Taking stock of two relational aspects of organizational life: Tracing the history and shaping the future of socialization and mentoring research.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2017
- Framing manipulations in contests: A natural field experimentJournal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2015
- The Effect of High-Performing Mentors on Junior Officer Promotion in the US ArmyJournal of Labor Economics, 2014
- The Cost of High-Powered Incentives: Employee Gaming in Enterprise Software SalesJournal of Labor Economics, 2014
- Does the stock market fully value intangibles? Employee satisfaction and equity pricesJournal of Financial Economics, 2011
- Personnel Economics: Hiring and Incentives2011
- The Structure of Wages and Investment in General TrainingJournal of Political Economy, 1999