Comparison of Biomechanical Characteristics and Pelvic Ring Stability Using Different Fixation Methods to Treat Pubic Symphysis Diastasis
Authors:
- Yu HeYHYu He
- Hebu QianHQHebu Qian
- Dongsheng ZhouDZDongsheng Zhou
- Qinghu LiQLQinghu Li
Open Access
- 1 December 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Medicine
- Vol. 94 (49) , e2207
Abstract
The intention of this study was to compare the biomechanical characteristics using 5 internal fixation methods used clinically to stabilize a pubic symphysis diastasis (PSD, Tile type B1). A 3-dimensional finite element model of PSD was simulated using 5 implants, including single superior plate (Single-Plate), superior and anterior plate (Dual-Plate), single cannulated screw (Single-Screw), crossed dual cannulated screws (Cross-Screw), and parallel dual cannulated screws (Para-Screw). Three loads were distributed in all models, including dual-leg standing, single-leg stance, and rotation. To evaluate the biomechanical properties, the construct stiffness, the stress distribution, and the von Misses stress were recorded and analyzed. To evaluate pelvic ring stability, the micromotion of the pubic symphysis and iliosacral joint was analyzed. Disruption of pubic symphysis dramatically decreased the pelvic ring stability. Cross-screw and Para-Screw showed higher stiffness than other methods. All implants endured the maximum von Misses stress under single-leg stance. For Plate-Screw system, the maximum stress occurred at a place where it strides over pubic symphysis and adjacent Plate-Screw interface. The single implant and Para-Screw had a tendency to fail. Para-Screw showed the best fixation effect under dual-leg conditions. Cross-screw showed superior antishearing force capacity under single-leg stance. Dual-Plate provided maximum antihorizontal rotation. Para-Screw provided the maximum stabilization for the posterior pelvic ring. This study showed the biomechanical advantages of dual-implant for PSD only from the finite element view. The Para-Screw provided high construct stiffness under 3 load conditions. The single implant and Para-Screw had a tendency to fail. The better anterior and posterior pelvic stabilization were obtained by the dual-implant fixation than other methods. Therefore, the Cross-Screw and Dual-Plate fixation methods should be preferred in the treatment of pubic symphysis from the finite element view.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Normal stress pattern of the pubic symphysisAnatomy & Cell Biology, 2014
- Mechanical comparison between lengthened and short sacroiliac screws in sacral fracture fixation: A finite element analysisOrthopaedics & Traumatology: Surgery & Research, 2013
- Biomechanical analysis of a new minimally invasive system for osteosynthesis of pubis symphysis disruptionInjury, 2012
- Radiographic Changes of Implant Failure After Plating for Pubic Symphysis Diastasis: An Underappreciated Reality?Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 2012
- A comparison of percutaneous reduction and screw fixation versus open reduction and plate fixation of traumatic symphysis pubis diastasisArchives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery, 2011
- Management outcomes in pubic diastasis: our experience with 19 patientsJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research, 2011
- Estimated prevalence of orthopaedic fractures in Taiwan—A cross-sectional study based on nationwide insurance dataInjury, 2010
- The adult human pubic symphysis: a systematic reviewJournal of Anatomy, 2010
- Stability of Open-Book Pelvic Fractures Using a New Biomechanical Model of Single-Limb StanceJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 1997
- The Effect of Laparotomy and External Fixator Stabilization on Pelvic Volume in an Unstable Pelvic InjuryThe Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, 1995