Understanding ‘Virtue’ and the Virtue of Understanding
- 4 September 2003
- book chapter
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 203-226
Abstract
This chapter offers an alternative to the standard success-oriented epistemological theories by arguing that the highest epistemic good is a state which includes much more than the achievement of true beliefs and the avoidance of false ones. Indeed, it includes much more than knowledge: it requires understanding of important truths. For some of the intellectual virtues are best understood as directed at understanding rather than truth or knowledge. Whether the goal of the intellectual virtues is truth or understanding, reliable success cannot be necessary for the possession of an intellectual virtue given that some of the most impressive intellectual giants such as Aristotle, Newton, and Galileo are not noted for their success. The intellectual virtues should therefore be understood in terms of the values at which they aim, not the values they reliably bring about. The upshot of giving up success oriented approaches in epistemology will provide greater clarity in understanding intellectual virtues.Keywords
This publication has 86 references indexed in Scilit:
- What is it like to be me?Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 1998
- What Are the “Chances” of Being Justified?The Monist, 1998
- Why Should Inquiring Minds Want to Know?The Monist, 1998
- Perspectives in virtue epistemology: A response to Dancy and BonjourPhilosophical Studies, 1995
- Sosa on knowledge, justification, and aptnessPhilosophical Studies, 1995
- Supervenience, virtues and consequences: A commentary onknowledge in perspective by Ernest SosaPhilosophical Studies, 1995
- The new critique of anti-consequentialist moral theoryPhilosophical Studies, 1993
- Virtue, Praise and SuccessThe Monist, 1990
- Moore and Wittgenstein as TeachersTeaching Philosophy, 1989
- Virtue and ReasonThe Monist, 1979