The Probability of Casting a Pivotal Vote in an Instant Runoff Voting Election
Author:
- 27 January 2025
- journal article
- letter
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Political Analysis
- Vol. 33 (4) , 447-455
Abstract
If instant runoff voting (IRV) mitigates strategic voting, is that because the rules of the system mechanically reduce strategic opportunities, or because of other more indirect effects? In single-vote plurality elections, a voter can be pivotal if adding one vote to a candidate would cause that candidate to win. In IRV, it is more complicated to identify when one voter can be pivotal. This letter derives all the ways that a single ballot can change the result of an IRV election, for any number of candidates and voters. I obtain an expression for the probability of casting a pivotal vote in IRV by phrasing the probability that any pivotal event occurs as a function of all the rankings cast by other voters. This expression facilitates modeling vote choice in IRV, and enables the estimation of voters’ strategic opportunities in IRV contests between any number of candidates. I present some illustrative simulations estimating pivotal probabilities in both IRV and Single-Member District Plurality for stylized electorates with identical preference structures. These simulations produce similar estimated pivotal probabilities in the two systems, suggesting that these systems may provide similar opportunities to strategically cast a decisive vote.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Analyzing Ballot Order Effects When Voters Rank CandidatesPolitical Analysis, 2024
- Does ranked choice Voting Increase voter turnout and mobilization?Electoral Studies, 2024
- Susceptibility to Strategic Voting: A Comparison of Plurality and Instant-Runoff ElectionsThe Journal of Politics, 2024
- Sincere, Strategic, or Something Else? The Impact of Ranked-Choice Voting on Voter Decision Making ProcessesAmerican Politics Research, 2024
- Civility in Ranked-Choice Voting Elections: Does Evidence Fit the Normative Narrative?Representation, 2023
- Ranked-Choice Voting and the Potential for Improved Electoral Performance of Third-Party Candidates in AmericaAmerican Politics Research, 2022
- Ranked Choice Voting in Australia and America: Do Voters Follow Party Cues?Politics and Governance, 2021
- A Theory of Strategic Voting in Runoff ElectionsAmerican Economic Review, 2013
- Unsettling aspects of voting theoryEconomic Theory, 2003
- Population uncertainty and Poisson gamesInternational Journal of Game Theory, 1998