A Preliminary Study of Silicone Hydrogel Lens Material and Care Solution Bioincompatibilities

Authors:
  • ANAndrew Loc Nguyen
    Andrew Loc Nguyen
  • JHJonathan Q Hall
    Jonathan Q Hall
  • DKDaniel Krall
    Daniel Krall
  • JWJustin R Webb
    Justin R Webb
  • ARAlison C Ramsey
    Alison C Ramsey
  • DMDavid L Meadows
    David L Meadows

Abstract
The study purpose was to evaluate corneal barrier function and staining relative to potential bioincompatibilities. This was a randomized double-masked study (n = 25 subjects). Three lens material-care solution combinations were tested: (1) lotrafilcon B/polyhexamethylene biguanide (PHMB)-based multipurpose (MPS) solution (MPS-1); (2) lotrafilcon B/polyquaternium-1 and myristamidopropyl dimethylamine-based solution (MPS-2); and (3) lotrafilcon B and another PHMB-based solution (MPS-3). Saline served as the control. New lenses were soaked in the preserved solutions or saline and then worn for 2 hours before corneal measurements. Barrier function was characterized by the fluorescein penetration rate, corneal amount, both measured with an objective scanning fluorometer. The dye penetration rate ratio, test to control; amount ratio, test to control, and corneal staining were evaluated. The mean rate ratios (± SD) for the combinations were 2.98 (± 3.04), 1.23 (± 1.01), and 1.83 (± 1.77) for MPS-1, MPS-2, and MPS-3 solutions, respectively. Significant ratio differences were found across regimens (P = 0.007); for MPS-1 compared with baseline (P = 0.031) and for MPS-1 compared with MPS-2 (P = 0.007). The statistical results for staining were similar. Use of an objective quantitative physiological method suggests that significant differences in lens solution bioincompatibilities occur that mirror corneal staining data relative to corneal compromise.

This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit: