Abstract
An early entrant's success may reflect lower costs, stronger demand, or gains from discouraging rivals. I show that timing and performance alone cannot distinguish these motives without restrictions on costs. For Japanese convenience stores, the model fits the same outlet patterns whether preemption explains all or none of the incentive to enter. A published cost estimate rules out some stated assumptions about future costs and entry incentives; under others, it limits preemption's contribution to 8.3%. The results show what additional cost and performance evidence is needed to measure preemption.

This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit: