Peer review contributions as a measure of academic distinction requirements of faculty promotion committees: rapid review of top-ranking universities
Open Access
- 25 September 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 11, 1859654
Abstract
Introduction: Journal peer review expertise is a cornerstone of academic practice. However, research publication productivity often overshadows prepublication peer review as a marker of academic distinction. The objective of this review is to examine the status of peer review contributions as a criterion of academic performance within faculty promotion committees at leading universities. Methods: We reviewed handbooks, guidelines, and procedures related to faculty promotion and tenure on the official websites of the top 50 universities ranked by the QS World University Rankings 2025. Peer review, as a requirement of academic promotion, was identified and reported if it fell within the scope of, a) peer review reporting or authoring, b) peer review education or mentoring, or c) peer review training or learning. The primary assessment criteria governing academic promotion were reported. Results: Eight universities were excluded due to unavailable or inaccessible information on their websites, and 42 were included in the final analysis. Only 15 (36%) of the included top-ranking universities explicitly mentioned peer review as a criterion for assessing academic distinction. Of the 15 universities, 14 (93%) mentioned peer review in the context of peer review reporting or authoring such as peer reviewing of scientific manuscripts, sitting on editorial boards of major journals, and participation on peer review grant panels. Only 1 (2%) university mentioned peer review in the context of peer review education or mentoring. Discussion: Peer review contributions as a measure of academic distinction requirements of faculty promotion committees in top ranking universities are underrepresented and underrated. Faculty promotion committees are urged to reconsider the relative weight of peer review contributions in the promotion review process.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Writing a Convincing Discussion Section2024
- Critical reflections on the journal peer review processHigher Education Research & Development, 2024
- Publishing review reports to reveal and preserve the quality and fairness of the peer review processEuropean Journal of Higher Education, 2023
- Team science criteria and processes for promotion and tenure of Health Science University FacultyJournal of Clinical and Translational Science, 2022
- Counting What Counts: Evolving the Criteria for Clinical Faculty Promotion in Medical SchoolsAcademic Medicine, 2022
- Peer Review in Academic Promotion of Excellent Teachers2022
- A review of U.S. Medical schools’ promotion standards for educational excellenceTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 2019
- How are clinician-educators evaluated for educational excellence? A survey of promotion and tenure committee members in the United StatesMedical Teacher, 2019
- Research Integrity, Academic Promotion, and Attribution of Authorship and Nonauthor ContributionsJAMA, 2017
- Automated Assessment of the Quality of Peer Reviews using Natural Language Processing TechniquesInternational Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education, 2017