In the Shadow of Justice: Postwar Liberalism and the Remaking of Political Philosophy, by Katrina Forrester
Author:
- 23 August 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Mind
- Vol. 133 (530) , 619-622
Abstract
Katrina Forrester’s book poses a problem for any reviewer that, I suspect, will be reflected in the experience of its readers. Unusually, the author is equally adept as a philosopher and as an historian. That poses the unique problem of establishing which theorist is speaking at any point in this narrative. The reason this is a problem is that, as the book develops, it is clear that Forrester the historian thinks that Rawls was at his most influential when his arguments were least understood. For those more sympathetic to Rawls, these historically influential arguments seem to bear little relation to Rawls’s work no matter how influential they were in the problematic ‘reception’ detailed here. Forrester the philosopher takes a more charitable view: she sympathetically engages with Rawls’s arguments in some of the most rewarding parts of this book. For long stretches, however, a reader sympathetic to Rawls is faced with the problem that a caricature of his views is, in this narrative, blamed for a great deal. Rawls’s influence has, in Forrester’s view, significantly diminished the political possibilities open to reflection no matter what the merits of his actual views.Keywords
This publication has 5 references indexed in Scilit: