Electoral and partisan consequences of sovereignty referendum outcomes: A comparative analysis
- 14 February 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Party Politics
- Vol. 32 (1) , 139-154
Abstract
What are the electoral consequences of winning a sovereignty referendum? While some argue that these referendums increase the electoral power of pro-sovereignty parties or even put in motion a slippery slope towards more (radical) demands, others sustain that sovereignty-related referendums are a “once in a generation” event, decrease the salience of territorial politics and hence the electoral appeal of pro-decentralisation parties. We put these narratives to the test using the newly compiled CONREF dataset, which includes comprehensive information on the type of sovereignty referendums, the party electoral outcomes before and after the referendum and their policy position. Our analysis shows no relationship between winning a sovereignty referendum and parties’ electoral fortunes. It also shows that referendums do not affect the territorial position of the parties–irrespective of the referendum outcome. If anything, we observe that the main party in the winner’s block loses support when the referendum passes by a small margin and that the opposition benefits when their side wins. In addition, looking at the EU referendums, we observe that when the position of anti-EU parties wins they become less Eurosceptic. Overall, our article improves our understanding of the dynamics of the winner-loser effects in sovereignty referendums and its spillovers to elections.Keywords
Funding Information
- Institut d'Estudis de l’Autogovern (PRE111/21/000011)
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dissimulate or disseminate? A survey on the fate of negative resultsLearned Publishing, 2022
- The Referendum that Changed a Nation2022
- Is the Québec Secession Movement Dead? Perspectives After Canada’s 2015 Federal Election2019
- The limits of partisan loyalty: How the Scottish independence referendum cost LabourElectoral Studies, 2018
- The Winner Takes It All: Revisiting the Effect of Direct Democracy on Citizens’ Political SupportPolitical Behavior, 2017
- Direct Democracy and Subjective Well-Being: The Initiative and Life Satisfaction in the American StatesSocial Indicators Research, 2015
- Does direct democracy make for better citizens? A cautionary warning based on cross-country evidenceConstitutional Political Economy, 2015
- Direct Democracy: Protest Catalyst or Protest Alternative?Political Behavior, 2012
- When Ballot Issues Matter: Social Issue Ballot Measures and Their Impact on TurnoutPolitical Behavior, 2010
- Initiative and Referendum2008