Abstract
The chapter considers whether severe deprivation may be a legitimate mitigating circumstance in sentencing. Such mitigation is currently allowed in some jurisdictions but prohibited in others. The approach of the chapter is to ask whether social deprivation may in some cases be a reason why lower than normal punishment is suitable and necessary to attain the goals of punishment (promotion and instantiation of equal freedom – or simply, crime prevention and upholding law). With this framing, the question is in part a matter of whether the social deprivation of an offender alters the meaning of the crime (its expressive content) compared to normal cases, and whether the expressive function of the sanction can then be served with less punishment. It is also in part a question of whether the offender’s lack of power and resources may imply that less than the normal amount of punishment is required. To both questions, the chapter argues that the answer is sometimes yes, and that a severe deprivation mitigation is then legitimate.