Making Progress in Age Stereotype Research
Authors:
- 1 October 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Work, Aging and Retirement
- Vol. 8 (4) , 383-385
Abstract
Murphy and DeNisi’s review suggested that the links between age and personnel decisions in organizations were generally weak and inconsistent and, on this basis, suggested that the effects of age stereotypes on these decisions might not be large. Fourteen papers commented on the evidence and arguments offered by Murphy and DeNisi. In our response, we comment on three broad themes running though this set of papers. First, several papers challenged the description of age effects as small and argued that age stereotypes can have negative effects and that older workers can be disadvantaged in the workplace. We fully agree but note that the size of the effects shown in our review and in the research cited by these commentaries effectively rules out the hypothesis that age stereotypes are consistently and strongly negative and that they have large effects in personnel decisions. Second, both context factors and intersectionality are suggested as potential moderators of age stereotype effects. We believe that progress in this area requires the development of specific models of these effects, and we offer examples. Third, many papers highlighted the challenges in studying age stereotype effects, in particular the failure of many studies to measure the stereotypes held by decision makers or to rule out factors unrelated to age stereotypes. We thus offer suggestions for improving age stereotype research.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Older Age Discrimination at Work: Not So Weak and FeebleWork, Aging and Retirement, 2022
- Age Stereotyping in Resume Screening: Don't Throw the Baby Out With the BathwaterWork, Aging and Retirement, 2022
- Precise Conclusions Regarding the Influence of Age Stereotypes Require Precise Operationalizations ThereofWork, Aging and Retirement, 2022
- The Confluence of Culture and Ageism at WorkWork, Aging and Retirement, 2022
- Multifaceted, Nuanced Personnel Decisions Necessitate Multifaceted, Nuanced Age Research ApproachesWork, Aging and Retirement, 2022
- Searching for the Effect of Age-Based Stereotypes on Personnel Decisions? Try Looking Through an Intersectional LensWork, Aging and Retirement, 2022
- Do Age Stereotypes Predict Personnel Decisions? The State of the EvidenceWork, Aging and Retirement, 2021
- Home and host distal context and performance appraisal in multinational enterprises: A 22 country studyHuman Resource Management, 2021
- Mend It or End ItOrganizational Research Methods, 2016
- Warmth of the Welcome: Attitudes Toward Immigrants and Immigration Policy in the United StatesAnnual Review of Sociology, 2014