Kevin R. Murphy
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Kevin R. Murphy has a total of 30 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Angelo DeNisi
Department of Management, Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA
2 shared publicationsAngelo S DeNisi
Department of Management, Tulane University , New Orleans, LA , USA
2 shared publications- Herman Aguinis
The George Washington University
2 shared publications Abigail Yavo
Telhai Academic College, Kyriat Shmone, Israel
1 shared publication- Aharon Tziner
Netanya Academic College, Israel
1 shared publication - Alma McCarthy
National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 17 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 65 (1) , 63-75
The Illusion of Performance Management
Despite the wide adoption of performance management by organizations, there is little evidence that performance management works. In this paper, I critique both the methods and the goals of performance management. First, I note that performance management, through its reliance on top‐down decision making, robs workers of autonomy and responsibility. Next, I note that two of the three major components of performance management (aligning job performance goals with the strategic goals of the organization and using frequent informal feedback to manage performance) are flawed, and that efforts to manage performance using these tools are likely to fail. Rather than relying on managing performance, organizations should follow decades of research on supportive leadership and focus on supporting and facilitating performance rather than managing it. I call for more empirical research to evaluate the effectiveness of performance management and the effects of the various tools used to manage performance.
- 17 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 65 (1) , 63-75
The Illusion of Performance Management
Despite the wide adoption of performance management by organizations, there is little evidence that performance management works. In this paper, I critique both the methods and the goals of performance management. First, I note that performance management, through its reliance on top‐down decision making, robs workers of autonomy and responsibility. Next, I note that two of the three major components of performance management (aligning job performance goals with the strategic goals of the organization and using frequent informal feedback to manage performance) are flawed, and that efforts to manage performance using these tools are likely to fail. Rather than relying on managing performance, organizations should follow decades of research on supportive leadership and focus on supporting and facilitating performance rather than managing it. I call for more empirical research to evaluate the effectiveness of performance management and the effects of the various tools used to manage performance.
- 18 March 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Vol. 17 (2) , 252-268
An epistemology for assessment and development: How do we know what we know?
To make informed decisions, assessment theorists, researchers, and practitioners can evaluate the overlap among (1) relevant theories, (2) empirical contributions, and (3) best practices. Unfortunately, such a task may seem daunting due to the so-called science-practice gap, which can thwart collaboration among these parties. This paper presents an epistemology for delineating the importance of integrating these three sources of knowledge. We then apply this epistemology to show that our current knowledge of assessment and development topics are well integrated in some places, but still quite lacking in others.
- 18 March 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Vol. 17 (2) , 252-268
An epistemology for assessment and development: How do we know what we know?
To make informed decisions, assessment theorists, researchers, and practitioners can evaluate the overlap among (1) relevant theories, (2) empirical contributions, and (3) best practices. Unfortunately, such a task may seem daunting due to the so-called science-practice gap, which can thwart collaboration among these parties. This paper presents an epistemology for delineating the importance of integrating these three sources of knowledge. We then apply this epistemology to show that our current knowledge of assessment and development topics are well integrated in some places, but still quite lacking in others.
- Open Access
- 6 November 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in IIM Ranchi Journal of Management Studies
- Vol. 2 (2) , 143-158
New approaches to dealing with performance management: getting rid of performance appraisals is not the answer
Purpose: This paper aims to review the challenges of performance appraisal in organizations and argue that these challenges can and must be overcome.Design/methodology/approach: The authors review research on performance appraisal in organizations and on claims that organizations are abandoning performance appraisal.Findings: Structured performance appraisals are still the norm in organizations around the world. There are clear and practical strategies for improving appraisals. These include improving feedback and removing unnecessary complexity, clarifying the goals of appraisal systems, focusing appraisal on behaviors and outcomes under the employee's control and increasing the fairness of appraisal systems.Research limitations/implications: Research is needed on the effects of changing the ways performance appraisals are conducted in organizations.Practical implications: Practical strategies for improving performance appraisal are outlined.Social implications: Better performance appraisals will benefit organizations and their members.Originality/value: This paper refutes the growing claim that organizations are abandoning performance appraisal and illustrates practical strategies for improving performance appraisal.
- 6 November 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in IIM Ranchi Journal of Management Studies
- Vol. 2 (2) , 143-158
Open AccessNew approaches to dealing with performance management: getting rid of performance appraisals is not the answer
Purpose: This paper aims to review the challenges of performance appraisal in organizations and argue that these challenges can and must be overcome.Design/methodology/approach: The authors review research on performance appraisal in organizations and on claims that organizations are abandoning performance appraisal.Findings: Structured performance appraisals are still the norm in organizations around the world. There are clear and practical strategies for improving appraisals. These include improving feedback and removing unnecessary complexity, clarifying the goals of appraisal systems, focusing appraisal on behaviors and outcomes under the employee's control and increasing the fairness of appraisal systems.Research limitations/implications: Research is needed on the effects of changing the ways performance appraisals are conducted in organizations.Practical implications: Practical strategies for improving performance appraisal are outlined.Social implications: Better performance appraisals will benefit organizations and their members.Originality/value: This paper refutes the growing claim that organizations are abandoning performance appraisal and illustrates practical strategies for improving performance appraisal.
- 31 August 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Vol. 16 (3) , 341-343
Interpreting validity evidence: It is time to end the horse race
- 31 August 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Vol. 16 (3) , 341-343
Interpreting validity evidence: It is time to end the horse race
- 4 November 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 93-109
HARKing: How Badly Can Cherry-Picking and Question Trolling Produce Bias in Published Results?
- 4 November 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 93-109
HARKing: How Badly Can Cherry-Picking and Question Trolling Produce Bias in Published Results?
- 1 October 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Work, Aging and Retirement
- Vol. 8 (4) , 383-385
Making Progress in Age Stereotype Research
Murphy and DeNisi’s review suggested that the links between age and personnel decisions in organizations were generally weak and inconsistent and, on this basis, suggested that the effects of age stereotypes on these decisions might not be large. Fourteen papers commented on the evidence and arguments offered by Murphy and DeNisi. In our response, we comment on three broad themes running though this set of papers. First, several papers challenged the description of age effects as small and argued that age stereotypes can have negative effects and that older workers can be disadvantaged in the workplace. We fully agree but note that the size of the effects shown in our review and in the research cited by these commentaries effectively rules out the hypothesis that age stereotypes are consistently and strongly negative and that they have large effects in personnel decisions. Second, both context factors and intersectionality are suggested as potential moderators of age stereotype effects. We believe that progress in this area requires the development of specific models of these effects, and we offer examples. Third, many papers highlighted the challenges in studying age stereotype effects, in particular the failure of many studies to measure the stereotypes held by decision makers or to rule out factors unrelated to age stereotypes. We thus offer suggestions for improving age stereotype research.
- 1 October 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Work, Aging and Retirement
- Vol. 8 (4) , 383-385
Making Progress in Age Stereotype Research
Murphy and DeNisi’s review suggested that the links between age and personnel decisions in organizations were generally weak and inconsistent and, on this basis, suggested that the effects of age stereotypes on these decisions might not be large. Fourteen papers commented on the evidence and arguments offered by Murphy and DeNisi. In our response, we comment on three broad themes running though this set of papers. First, several papers challenged the description of age effects as small and argued that age stereotypes can have negative effects and that older workers can be disadvantaged in the workplace. We fully agree but note that the size of the effects shown in our review and in the research cited by these commentaries effectively rules out the hypothesis that age stereotypes are consistently and strongly negative and that they have large effects in personnel decisions. Second, both context factors and intersectionality are suggested as potential moderators of age stereotype effects. We believe that progress in this area requires the development of specific models of these effects, and we offer examples. Third, many papers highlighted the challenges in studying age stereotype effects, in particular the failure of many studies to measure the stereotypes held by decision makers or to rule out factors unrelated to age stereotypes. We thus offer suggestions for improving age stereotype research.
- 9 May 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Management
- Vol. 48 (8) , 2159-2166
Reporting Interaction Effects: Visualization, Effect Size, and Interpretation
Most management theories include hypotheses about interaction effects (i.e., the relation between two variables depends on values of another), but it is common for articles to present results that make it difficult to evaluate the nature, strength, and importance of the effect. We offer recommendations for improving the reporting of interaction effects by focusing on (a) visualizations, (b) effect size estimates, and (c) assessments of the nature, meaning, and importance of interactions for theory and practice.
- 9 May 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Management
- Vol. 48 (8) , 2159-2166
Reporting Interaction Effects: Visualization, Effect Size, and Interpretation
Most management theories include hypotheses about interaction effects (i.e., the relation between two variables depends on values of another), but it is common for articles to present results that make it difficult to evaluate the nature, strength, and importance of the effect. We offer recommendations for improving the reporting of interaction effects by focusing on (a) visualizations, (b) effect size estimates, and (c) assessments of the nature, meaning, and importance of interactions for theory and practice.
- 11 February 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 153-178
Surviving the Statistical Arms Race
The methods that are used to analyze data in organizational research are increasingly complex and diverse; a survey of all the articles published in two years in two leading journals reveals a wide mix of analytic methods for tackling what are often similar questions. While complex data analysis methods sometimes allow researchers to tackle questions that would evade simpler methods, the likelihood that complex data analyses are performed correctly and, more important, interpreted correctly is likely to decrease as complexity increases. As methods depart from the familiar frameworks of ANOVA and OLS regression, they have become increasingly dependent on null hypothesis tests and are less likely to report interpretable effect size measures. I illustrate the trade-off between complexity and interpretability by showing how these the key components of these significance tests (i.e., standard error terms) become increasingly difficult to understand as analyses become more complex. I describe ways researchers could make better use of descriptive statistics to make data analyses more meaningful and more interpretable, and I lay out the analytic tools that are most likely to prove useful to organizational scientists who wish to understand what their data mean.
- 11 February 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 153-178
Surviving the Statistical Arms Race
The methods that are used to analyze data in organizational research are increasingly complex and diverse; a survey of all the articles published in two years in two leading journals reveals a wide mix of analytic methods for tackling what are often similar questions. While complex data analysis methods sometimes allow researchers to tackle questions that would evade simpler methods, the likelihood that complex data analyses are performed correctly and, more important, interpreted correctly is likely to decrease as complexity increases. As methods depart from the familiar frameworks of ANOVA and OLS regression, they have become increasingly dependent on null hypothesis tests and are less likely to report interpretable effect size measures. I illustrate the trade-off between complexity and interpretability by showing how these the key components of these significance tests (i.e., standard error terms) become increasingly difficult to understand as analyses become more complex. I describe ways researchers could make better use of descriptive statistics to make data analyses more meaningful and more interpretable, and I lay out the analytic tools that are most likely to prove useful to organizational scientists who wish to understand what their data mean.
- Open Access
- 14 December 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Vol. 14 (4) , 461-477
In praise of Table 1: The importance of making better use of descriptive statistics
As data analytic methods in the managerial sciences become more sophisticated, the gap between the descriptive data typically presented in Table 1 and the analyses used to test the principal hypotheses advanced has become increasingly large. This contributes to several problems including: (1) the increasing likelihood that analyses presented in published research will be performed and/or interpreted incorrectly, (2) an increasing reliance on statistical significance as the principal criterion for evaluating results, and (3) the increasing difficulty of describing our research and explaining our findings to non-specialists. A set of simple methods for assessing whether hypotheses about interventions, moderator relationships and mediation, are plausible that are based on the simplest possible examination of descriptive statistics are proposed.
- 14 December 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Vol. 14 (4) , 461-477
Open AccessIn praise of Table 1: The importance of making better use of descriptive statistics
As data analytic methods in the managerial sciences become more sophisticated, the gap between the descriptive data typically presented in Table 1 and the analyses used to test the principal hypotheses advanced has become increasingly large. This contributes to several problems including: (1) the increasing likelihood that analyses presented in published research will be performed and/or interpreted incorrectly, (2) an increasing reliance on statistical significance as the principal criterion for evaluating results, and (3) the increasing difficulty of describing our research and explaining our findings to non-specialists. A set of simple methods for assessing whether hypotheses about interventions, moderator relationships and mediation, are plausible that are based on the simplest possible examination of descriptive statistics are proposed.
- Open Access
- 13 October 2021
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in The Irish Journal of Management
- Vol. 40 (2) , 78-85
Life After COVID-19: What if We Never go Back to the Office?
The COVID-19 pandemic has led to a substantial increase in the use of remote work for occupations where this modality is feasible. This paper speculates on the likely outcome of this unplanned experiment by asking what might happen if we never go back to the office. I predict that: (1) managers will find an adjustment to permanent remote work difficult, (2) some tasks will become increasingly difficult to perform, (3) female employees will suffer, (4) many employees will respond positively to doing away with the office, but this response will be far from universal, and (5) organizations will thrive, particularly organizations that are already rich and powerful.
- 13 October 2021
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in The Irish Journal of Management
- Vol. 40 (2) , 78-85
Open AccessLife After COVID-19: What if We Never go Back to the Office?
The COVID-19 pandemic has led to a substantial increase in the use of remote work for occupations where this modality is feasible. This paper speculates on the likely outcome of this unplanned experiment by asking what might happen if we never go back to the office. I predict that: (1) managers will find an adjustment to permanent remote work difficult, (2) some tasks will become increasingly difficult to perform, (3) female employees will suffer, (4) many employees will respond positively to doing away with the office, but this response will be far from universal, and (5) organizations will thrive, particularly organizations that are already rich and powerful.