In defense of clinical judgment … and mechanical prediction
Authors:
- 24 November 2006
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 19 (5) , 413-428
Abstract
Despite over 50 years of one‐sided research favoring formal prediction rules over human judgment, the “clinical‐statistical controversy,” as it has come to be known, remains something of a hot‐button issue. Surveying the objections to the formal approach, it seems the strongest point of disagreement is that clinical expertise can be replaced by statistics. We review and expand upon an unfortunately obscured part of Meehl's book to try to reconcile the issue. Building on Meehl, we argue that the clinician provides information that cannot be captured in, or outperformed by, mere frequency tables. However, that information is still best harnessed by a mechanical prediction rule that makes the ultimate decision. Two original studies support our arguments. The first study shows that multivariate prediction models using no data other than clinical speculations can perform well against statistical regression models. Study 2, however, showed that holistic predictions were less accurate than predictions made by mechanically combining smaller judgments without input from the judge at the combination stage. While we agree that clinical expertise cannot be replaced or neglected, we see no ethical reason to resist using explicit, mechanical rules for socially important decisions. Copyright © 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Random error reduction in analytic hierarchies: a comparison of holistic and decompositional decision strategiesJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2001
- Problems for Judgment and Decision MakingAnnual Review of Psychology, 2001
- Accountability: A social magnifier of the dilution effect.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1989
- Evaluation, Diagnosis, and Prediction in Parole Decision MakingLaw & Society Review, 1982
- Interactive Elicitation of Opinion for a Normal Linear ModelJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1980
- Estimating coefficients in linear models: It don't make no nevermind.Psychological Bulletin, 1976
- Linear models in decision making.Psychological Bulletin, 1974
- Expert measurement and mechanical combinationOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1972
- The general and the unique in psychological science1Journal of Personality, 1962
- Clinical versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the EvidenceThe American Journal of Psychology, 1955