Comparing regulatory options: the role of epistemic policies and pragmatic consequences
- 22 November 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Science and Public Policy
- Vol. 51 (3) , 352-359
Abstract
The controversies surrounding the regulation of technology depend, among other factors, on the diversity of the regulatory objectives prioritized by the distinct social actors. These differences may also lead to controversies in the realm of regulatory science: controversies between distinct epistemic policies. As controversies are partly the result of prioritizing different objectives, comparing alternative regulatory options is a seemingly impossible endeavour. In this paper, we offer a partial solution to this problem by proposing a means of comparing different regulatory options. This proposal makes it possible to analyse and assess the different options and facilitates the adoption of compromises between the various parties to the controversy, even if it is unable to eliminate the differences in the prioritization of objectives. The case study we have used to illustrate the main ideas of this paper is the controversy surrounding the regulation of health claims in the European Union.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación - Agencia Estatal de Investigación (PID2020-113449GB-I00 PRE2018-085271)
- Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación - Agencia Estatal de Investigación (PID2020-113449GB-I00 PRE2018-085271)
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- How should we define health?BMJ, 2011
- Food & health forum meeting: evidence-based nutritionBritish Journal of Nutrition, 2010
- Evidence-based criteria in the nutritional contextNutrition Reviews, 2010
- The role of risks and uncertainties in technological conflicts: three strategies of constructing ignoranceInnovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 2009
- European Union regulation of agri-biotechnology: precautionary links between science, expertise and policyScience and Public Policy, 2005
- Values in science and risk assessmentToxicology Letters, 2004
- Inductive Risk and Values in SciencePhilosophy of Science, 2000
- Genetically modified crops in the European Union: regulatory conflicts as precautionary opportunitiesJournal of Risk Research, 2000
- Regulation as a means for the social control of technologyTechnology Analysis & Strategic Management, 1994
- Controversies as Informal Technology A ssessmentKnowledge, 1986