Kinder, gentler – and crisis-proof? Consensus democracy, inclusive institutions and COVID-19 pandemic performance
- 16 January 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in West European Politics
- Vol. 46 (6) , 1106-1132
Abstract
Which patterns of democracy perform best? Although a decades-long research tradition has fairly robustly suggested that consensual democracies outperform their Westminster-style majoritarian counterparts, the scope of previous studies has been limited to ‘normal times’. In this article, the endogenous context of the COVID-19 pandemic is leveraged to study whether the alleged superiority of consensualism also holds during crises. It is hypothesised that, in addition to consensus democracy, inclusive institutions – i.e. cabinet size and interest-group corporatism – enhance crisis-related performance. Drawing on new and original data, cross-sectional and hierarchical time-series regression analyses show that horizontal power-sharing and the number of ministers substantively reduced excess mortality, while the structure of the interest-group system had no effect. Although established consensus democracies can draw on their built-in institutional assets even during crises, our findings indicate that majoritarian systems may, as a compensatory performance-enhancing tool, flexibly gear up for crisis-induced necessities by adding more ministers to the cabinet.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cabinet structure and fiscal policy outcomesEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2010
- Review Article: Democratic Inclusiveness: A Reinterpretation of Lijphart’sPatterns of DemocracyBritish Journal of Political Science, 2010
- Lijphart expanded: three dimensions of democracy in advanced OECD countries?European Political Science Review, 2009
- The Wisdom of Many in One MindPsychological Science, 2009
- Cabinet Reshuffles and Ministerial DriftBritish Journal of Political Science, 2008
- Business “Not” as Usual: The National Incident Management System, Federalism, and LeadershipPublic Administration Review, 2007
- Nested Analysis as a Mixed-Method Strategy for Comparative ResearchAmerican Political Science Review, 2005
- Political performance and types of democracy: Findings from comparative studiesEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2002
- Two Models of DemocracyJournal of Democracy, 2001
- Political Science and the Three New InstitutionalismsPolitical Studies, 1996