Mechanism-Based Classification and Quantitative Assessment of Panoramic Radiographic Artifacts
- 24 August 2026
- journal article
- Published by Hacettepe University Faculty of Dentistry in Clinical Dentistry and Research
- Vol. 50 (2) , 138-147
Abstract
Background and Aim: Accurate identification of panoramicradiographic artifacts is essential for improving diagnosticreliability and reducing unnecessary repeat imaging. This studyaimed to classify panoramic radiographic artifacts by theirformation mechanisms and evaluate image quality using thecumulative artifact burden based on total artifact count.Materials and Methods: This retrospective study included 500panoramic radiographs. Images were classified into eight artifactcategories, and the cumulative artifact burden was calculated fromthe total artifact count. Inter-observer agreement was assessedusing Cohen’s kappa(κ), and reliability of the total artifact countusing the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).Results: A total of 500 panoramic radiographs were evaluated. Atleast one artifact was identified in 92.0% of radiographs, whereasonly 8.0% were artifact-free. According to the predefined imagequality classification, 8.0% of radiographs were classified asexcellent, 62.6% as acceptable, and 29.4% as unacceptable.Air space–related soft tissue artifacts were the most frequentfindings, with improper tongue positioning observed in 43.6% ofimages. Transverse and vertical positioning artifacts were alsocommon, whereas motion artifacts were relatively infrequent(3.0%). Inter-observer agreement demonstrated substantial toalmost perfect reliability, with Cohen’s kappa values ranging from0.80 to 0.92 and excellent agreement for total artifact countassessment (ICC = 0.958).Conclusion: A mechanism-based classification combinedwith an artifact count–based burden assessment may providea structured approach for evaluating panoramic imagequality, although further validation is needed to determine itsrelationship with diagnostic acceptability.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Radiation exposure in recurrent medical imaging: identifying drivers and high-risk populationsFrontiers in Public Health, 2025
- Evaluation of Common Diagnostic Errors in Panoramic Radiographs and Interobserver Agreement in Error IdentificationMedical Records, 2025
- Principles of radiological protection and application of ALARA, ALADA, and ALADAIP: a critical reviewBrazilian Oral Research, 2025
- Assessment of Panoramic Radiograph Errors: An Evaluation of Patient Preparation and Positioning Quality at Soelastri Dental and Oral HospitalThe Open Dentistry Journal, 2023
- Panoramic radiography and patients with disability: a new simple breathing technique to reduce common airspace errorJournal of Medical Radiation Sciences, 2022
- Basic Knowledge and New Advances in Panoramic Radiography Imaging Techniques: A Narrative Review on What Dentists and Radiologists Should KnowApplied Sciences, 2021
- Determination of different positioning errors in digital panoramic radiography: A retrospective studyJournal of Medicine, Radiology, Pathology & Surgery, 2019
- An investigation in to the impact of acquisition location on error type and rate when undertaking panoramic radiographyRadiography, 2017
- Positioning errors in digital panoramic radiographs: A studyJournal of Orofacial Sciences, 2016
- The quality of panoramic radiographs in a sample of general dental practicesBritish Dental Journal, 1999