The objective of this paper is to present findings where measured subgrade stresses from vehicular traffic and the Falling Weight Deflectometer (FWD) are compared. Both loading techniques were employed on a heavily instrumented pavement under identical conditions during a period immediately after construction. The analysis presented clearly showed that the difference in pressure response in the compacted subgrade of a thin flexible pavement was statistically significant with vehicular traffic producing higher values in every instance. FWD readings, on average, would need to be increased by a factors of 3.73 and 2.39 for the front and back axles, respectively, to prevent statistical differences from being detected. Such a large difference in pressure response is significant since the FWD is routinely used to, among many other functions, back calculate layer moduli of stress softening soils.