Balancing Resource Circularity and Farm Profitability: A Secondary Probabilistic Bioeconomic Assessment of Partial Nutrient Solution Recirculation in a Korean Indoor Strawberry System
Open Access
- 22 September 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (19) , 9703
Abstract
Partial nutrient-solution recirculation can improve resource efficiency without establishing net environmental sustainability or private profitability. This secondary bioeconomic assessment used four fixed-layout operational records per setting for 0%, 30%, and 50% recirculation in a Korean two-tier indoor aeroponic strawberry system. Resource indicators were integrated with partial budgeting, 200,000-draw Monte Carlo simulations, downside-risk measures, complementary uncertainty cases, Sobol sensitivity analysis, and capital-recovery and avoided-discharge shadow-value frontiers. Thirty-percent recirculation reduced freshwater make-up by 30.0% and freshwater intensity by 28.3%, while retaining 97.7% of control yield. At the base price and tariff, its incremental margin was −8364 Korean won (KRW), approximately −6.09 United States dollars (USD), per (25/3) m2 block-cycle; parity required 98.54% yield retention. With the observed mean yield difference fixed, the scenario-conditional positive-margin probability was only 2.95%. It was 24.94% under four-record empirical resampling and 55.35% under an exploratory triangular yield envelope, falling to 16.56% when declared labor and energy/consumables burdens were added to that envelope. The triangular result interpolates across sparse, non-independent records and is not a more empirically supported probability estimate. All probabilities assume independent model inputs and retained, incompletely auditable fertilizer-cost allocations. Fifty-percent recirculation remained unfavorable because yield losses outweighed input savings. These findings identify a resource–profitability trade-off, not an environmentally sustainable or optimal recirculation rate; numerical conclusions require independent crop-, facility-, and market-specific evidence.Keywords
Funding Information
- Rural Development Administration (RS-2025-02303245)
- Korea Institute of Planning and Evaluation for Technology in Food, Agriculture and Forestry (IPET) and the Korea Smart Farm R&D Foundation
- Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (RS-2024-00400250)
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sodium accumulation management in a closed-loop soilless cropping system using ion selective electrodes and a novel Decision Support SystemSmart Agricultural Technology, 2025
- Development and validation of an innovative algorithm for sodium accumulation management in closed-loop soilless culture systemsAgricultural Water Management, 2024
- Current perspective on nutrient solution management strategies to improve the nutrient and water use efficiency in hydroponic systemsCanadian Journal of Plant Science, 2024
- Improving water use efficiency in vertical farming: Effects of growing systems, far-red radiation and planting density on lettuce cultivationAgricultural Water Management, 2023
- Improvement and validation of a decision support system to maintain optimal nutrient levels in crops grown in closed-loop soilless systemsAgricultural Water Management, 2023
- A production capacity investment decision-making tool for the indoor vertical farming industrySmart Agricultural Technology, 2023
- Exploring the landscape of controlled environment agriculture research: A systematic scoping review of trends and topicsAgricultural Systems, 2023
- Global Sensitivity Analysis. The Primer2007
- Disinfestation of recirculating nutrient solutions in greenhouse horticultureAgronomy for Sustainable Development, 2001
- Risk Analysis of Adopting Zero Runoff Subirrigation Systems in Greenhouse Operations: A Monte Carlo Simulation ApproachAgricultural and Resource Economics Review, 2000