Omnisubjectivity, counteractuals, and relating perfectly to subjectivity
Author:
Open Access
- 5 March 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Religious Studies
- Vol. 62 (4) , 919-932
Abstract
The idea that God must relate perfectly to our subjectivity is central to Linda Zagzebski’s work on omnisubjectivity. There is a hitherto undiagnosed tension, however, between different criteria one might use to judge what perfectly relating to our subjectivity consists in. God’s relationship to what Zagzebski calls ‘counteractuals’, individuals that do not exist but that could have, brings this tension into focus. On the one hand, if God does not know what the subjective experiences of counteractuals would be like, then God’s omnisubjectivity would appear to be unacceptably limited in scope. On the other hand, if God knows the subjectivity of actual creatures in the same way that God knows the subjectivity of counteractual creatures, then the motivation for omnisubjectivity ends up being undercut to a significant extent. This essay resolves this tension with a model that draws on interpersonal perception and divine introspection.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Aquinas On Being, Goodness, And Divine SimplicityNew Blackfriars, 2023
- Omnisubjectivity2023
- Omnisubjectivity and the problem of creepy divine emotionsReligious Studies, 2020
- Wandering in Darkness2010
- Omnisubjectivity2008
- God and Phenomenal Consciousness2008
- Simulating Minds2006
- Action Observation and Acquired Motor Skills: An fMRI Study with Expert DancersCerebral Cortex, 2004
- Mental Imagery of Faces and Places Activates Corresponding Stimulus-Specific Brain RegionsJournal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 2000
- Sympathy, Simulation, and the Impartial SpectatorEthics, 1995