A dynamic simulator for the ergonomics evaluation of powered torque tools for human assembly
- 6 February 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Assembly Automation
- Vol. 37 (1) , 1-12
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study is to design and develop a testing device to simulate interaction between human hand–arm dynamics, right-angle (RA) computer-controlled power torque tools and joint-tightening task-related variables. Design/methodology/approach: The testing rig can simulate a variety of tools, tasks and operator conditions. The device includes custom data-acquisition electronics and graphical user interface-based software. The simulation of the human hand–arm dynamics is based on the rig’s four-bar mechanism-based design and mechanical components that provide adjustable stiffness (via pneumatic cylinder) and mass (via plates) and non-adjustable damping. The stiffness and mass values used are based on an experimentally validated hand–arm model that includes a database of model parameters. This database is with respect to gender and working posture, corresponding to experienced tool operators from a prior study. Findings: The rig measures tool handle force and displacement responses simultaneously. Peak force and displacement coefficients of determination (R2) between rig estimations and human testing measurements were 0.98 and 0.85, respectively, for the same set of tools, tasks and operator conditions. The rig also provides predicted tool operator acceptability ratings, using a data set from a prior study of discomfort in experienced operators during torque tool use. Research limitations/implications: Deviations from linearity may influence handle force and displacement measurements. Stiction (Coulomb friction) in the overall rig, as well as in the air cylinder piston, is neglected. The rig’s mechanical damping is not adjustable, despite the fact that human hand–arm damping varies with respect to gender and working posture. Deviations from these assumptions may affect the correlation of the handle force and displacement measurements with those of human testing for the same tool, task and operator conditions. Practical implications: This test rig will allow the rapid assessment of the ergonomic performance of DC torque tools, saving considerable time in lineside applications and reducing the risk of worker injury. DC torque tools are an extremely effective way of increasing production rate and improving torque accuracy. Being a complex dynamic system, however, the performance of DC torque tools varies in each application. Changes in worker mass, damping and stiffness, as well as joint stiffness and tool program, make each application unique. This test rig models all of these factors and allows quick assessment. Social implications: The use of this tool test rig will help to identify and understand risk factors that contribute to musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) associated with the use of torque tools. Tool operators are subjected to large impulsive handle reaction forces, as joint torque builds up while tightening a fastener. Repeated exposure to such forces is associated with muscle soreness, fatigue and physical stress which are also risk factors for upper extremity injuries (MSDs; e.g. tendinosis, myofascial pain). Eccentric exercise exertions are known to cause damage to muscle tissue in untrained individuals and affect subsequent performance. Originality/value: The rig provides a novel means for quantitative, repeatable dynamic evaluation of RA powered torque tools and objective selection of tightening programs. Compared to current static tool assessment methods, dynamic testing provides a more realistic tool assessment relative to the tool operator’s experience. This may lead to improvements in tool or controller design and reduction in associated musculoskeletal discomfort in operators.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Methods for deriving a representative biodynamic response of the hand–arm system to vibrationJournal of Sound and Vibration, 2009
- Prolonged mechanical and physiological changes in the upper extremity following short-term simulated power hand tool useErgonomics, 2009
- Effects of user experience, working posture and joint hardness on powered nutrunner torque reactionsErgonomics, 2007
- Power Hand Tool Kinetics Associated with Upper Limb Injuries in an Automobile Assembly PlantJournal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 2007
- Handle Dynamics Predictions for Selected Power Hand Tool ApplicationsHuman Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 2003
- Forces associated with pneumatic power screwdriver operation: statics and dynamicsErgonomics, 2003
- Muscle damage from eccentric exercise: mechanism, mechanical signs, adaptation and clinical applicationsThe Journal of Physiology, 2001
- The influence of target torque and torque build-up time on physical stress in right angle nutrunner operationErgonomics, 1998
- Muscle response to pneumatic hand tool torque reaction forcesErgonomics, 1989
- Dynamic response of the hand-arm system to a sinusoidal inputJournal of Sound and Vibration, 1972