A study of Type B uncertainties associated with the photoelectric effect in low-energy Monte Carlo simulations
Open Access
- 14 May 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 66 (10) , 105014
Abstract
Purpose. To estimate Type B uncertainties in absorbed-dose calculations arising from the different implementations in current state-of-the-art Monte Carlo (MC) codes of low-energy photon cross-sections (Methods. MC simulations are carried out using three codes widely used in the low-energy domain: PENELOPE-2018, EGSnrc, and MCNP. Three dosimetry-relevant quantities are considered: mass energy-absorption coefficients for water, air, graphite, and their respective ratios; absorbed dose; and photon-fluence spectra. The absorbed dose and the photon-fluence spectra are scored in a spherical water phantom of 15 cm radius. Benchmark simulations using similar cross-sections have been performed. The differences observed between these quantities when different cross-sections are considered are taken to be a good estimator for the corresponding Type B uncertainties. Results. A conservative Type B uncertainty for the absorbed dose ( k = 2) of 1.2%–1.7% (k = 2) of about 1.5% (water and air), and 2% (graphite), diminishing in all materials for larger energies and reaching values about 1% (40–50 keV) and 0.5% (50–75 keV). With respect to their ratios, the only significant Type B uncertainties are observed in the case of the water-to-graphite ratio for energies below 30 keV, being about 0.7% ( k = 2). Conclusions. In contrast with the intermediate (about 500 keV) or high (about 1 MeV) energy domains, Type B uncertainties due to the different cross-sections implementation cannot be considered subdominant with respect to Type A uncertainties or even to other sources of Type B uncertainties (tally volume averaging, manufacturing tolerances, etc). Therefore, the values reported here should be accommodated within the uncertainty budget in low-energy photon dosimetry studies.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (PGC2018-101302-B)
- Generalitat Valenciana (AICO/2019/132)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Measurement of the mass energy-absorption coefficient of air for x-rays in the range from 3 to 60 keVPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2012
- Contact radiotherapy using a 50kV X-ray system: Evaluation of relative dose distribution with the Monte Carlo code PENELOPE and comparison with measurementsRadiation Physics and Chemistry, 2012
- X-ray incoherent scattering total cross sections and energy-absorption cross sections by means of simple calculation routinesPhysical Review A, 1983
- Incoherent-x-ray-scattering functions and cross sectionsby means of a pocket calculatorPhysical Review A, 1982
- Pair, Triplet, and Total Atomic Cross Sections (and Mass Attenuation Coefficients) for 1 MeV-100 GeV Photons in Elements Z=1 to 100Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data, 1980
- Hartree-Fock Compton profiles for the elementsAtomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables, 1975
- Atomic Photoelectric Effect Above 10 keVReviews of Modern Physics, 1973
- Photoeffect from theShellPhysical Review B, 1960
- Über den atomaren Photoeffekt in der K‐Schale nach der relativistischen Wellenmechanik DiracsAnnalen der Physik, 1931
- Beiträge zur Theorie der Absorption von RöntgenstrahlenAnnalen der Physik, 1931