When Is a Market Not a Market?: ‘Exemption’, ‘Externality’ and ‘Exception’ in the Case of European State Aid Rules
- 6 February 2013
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Theory, Culture & Society
- Vol. 30 (2) , 32-59
Abstract
The reach of markets and market-based forms of valuation is never unlimited in any society, which invites empirical and political questions regarding how limits to markets are instituted, justified and enforced. Under neoliberalism, the state performs a key role in expanding the reach of markets and associated principles and techniques of valuation, using law and governmental techniques. But this then poses a question of the relationship between the neoliberal state and the market that it endorses and enforces: is the state internal or external to the market order that it helps to construct? European Union state aid rules provide an empirical entry point to consider such questions, providing a combination of normative, technical and sovereign principles, via which the division between state and market can be justified, tested and enacted. The article identifies three separate though overlapping logics within state aid documents, each of which offers the state a justification for suspending the competitive market order: exemptions, in which non-market values are upheld, externalities, in which markets are shown to be technically inefficient, and exceptions – such as the 2008 financial crisis – in which the state abandons the market to save the market.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Economic advice as a vocation: symbioses of scientific and political authorityThe British Journal of Sociology, 2011
- Discretion by the rules: European state aid policy and the 1999 Procedural RegulationJournal of European Public Policy, 2010
- Morals and politics in the ideology of neo-liberalismSocio-Economic Review, 2010
- Revisiting 50 years of market-making: The neoliberal transformation of European competition policyReview of International Political Economy, 2010
- Economics and the ‘nonsense’ of law: the case of the Chicago antitrust revolutionEconomy and Society, 2010
- The production of hegemonic policy discourses: ‘competitiveness’ as a knowledge brand and its (re-)contextualizationsCritical Policy Studies, 2009
- Moral Views of Market SocietyAnnual Review of Sociology, 2007
- The Sociology of Critical CapacityEuropean Journal of Social Theory, 1999
- Constitutionalizing the Economy: German Neo-Liberalism, Competition Law and the "New" EuropeThe American Journal of Comparative Law, 1994
- The Problem of Social CostThe Journal of Law and Economics, 1960