Abstract
This chapter uses the multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework to look at the very broad topic of quantitative reasoning, which includes two sharply contrasting theoretical viewpoints. In contrast to the relatively brief examples in Chapter 4, this is a challenging situation that shows how the MCL framework can be used as a common reference to usefully structure, understand, and equitably evaluate a complex body of research and ideas. The MCL framework also fosters the identification of gaps and conflicts in knowledge that highlight opportunities for key further research. The topic of quantitative reasoning reaches into broader issues of how to define and understand human rationality, and two underlying views on rationality (constrained maximization and extended adaptations) lead to two different models of quantitative reasoning (constrained maximization and expanded adaptations views). These two views are often contrasted against each other not just in quantitative reasoning generally, but in the specific topic of Bayesian reasoning. The resulting dual-process and favored formats models of Bayesian reasoning are systematically compared at the intentional level (theoretical and phylogenetic evidence), at the algorithmic level (psychological, developmental, cross-cultural, ancestral environments, and medical lines of evidence), and at the biological level (physiological and genetic evidence).