Gary L. Brase
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Gary L. Brase has a total of 163 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Larry E. Erickson
Tim Taylor Department of Chemical Engineering, Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS 66506, USA
17 shared publications James R. Daugherty
4 shared publications- Lora Adair
Department of Psychology, Brunel University of London, London UB8 3PH, UK
4 shared publications - Jordann L. Brandner
Department of Psychology, Elon University, Elon, USA
3 shared publications Laurence Fiddick
Departments of Interdisciplinary Studies and Psychology, Lakehead University, Orillia Campus, 955 Oliver Road, Thunder Bay, Ontario P7B 5E1, Canada
3 shared publications- Nora Balboa
Kansas State University
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 9 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 39 (5)
Icon Arrays: A Key to Pictures That Effectively Aid Statistical Reasoning
Statistical reasoning is often aided by a picture illustrating the data, but why pictures help is a matter of both empirical and theoretical debate. To help resolve both types of debates, this research compared identical reasoning tasks with pictures of the same overall shape but different internal features. Experiment 1 found that the best performances occurred when people were given clearly distinct icons (either organized or scattered), followed by overlapping icons, and the worst performance was with a picture of solid fields (no icons). Experiment 2, with a different and more complex reasoning task, found the best performances again with distinct icons (organized or scattered) and the poorest performance with the solid field picture (slightly below a control condition of no picture). Experiment 3 further replicated and extended these findings across different texts, icons, and colors. Participants also completed measures of numerical literacy, visuospatial ability, set reasoning ability, graph literacy, and nonmathematical cognitive reflection. All were correlated with Bayesian reasoning performance, as well as each other, but only numeracy showed consistent predictive ability. In addition to practical implications for effective communication of quantitative information, these results support a view that the mind is designed to more effectively use discrete individuated items in statistical reasoning.
- 9 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 39 (5)
Icon Arrays: A Key to Pictures That Effectively Aid Statistical Reasoning
Statistical reasoning is often aided by a picture illustrating the data, but why pictures help is a matter of both empirical and theoretical debate. To help resolve both types of debates, this research compared identical reasoning tasks with pictures of the same overall shape but different internal features. Experiment 1 found that the best performances occurred when people were given clearly distinct icons (either organized or scattered), followed by overlapping icons, and the worst performance was with a picture of solid fields (no icons). Experiment 2, with a different and more complex reasoning task, found the best performances again with distinct icons (organized or scattered) and the poorest performance with the solid field picture (slightly below a control condition of no picture). Experiment 3 further replicated and extended these findings across different texts, icons, and colors. Participants also completed measures of numerical literacy, visuospatial ability, set reasoning ability, graph literacy, and nonmathematical cognitive reflection. All were correlated with Bayesian reasoning performance, as well as each other, but only numeracy showed consistent predictive ability. In addition to practical implications for effective communication of quantitative information, these results support a view that the mind is designed to more effectively use discrete individuated items in statistical reasoning.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Evolutionary Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 20 (3) , 217-227
Who makes the cut? Investigating the interaction of relatedness and donation cost on the decision to donate organs.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Evolutionary Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 20 (3) , 217-227
Who makes the cut? Investigating the interaction of relatedness and donation cost on the decision to donate organs.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in MetaArXiv
Assessments of Credibility in the Social and Behavioral Sciences
Credibility assessment — determining whether research findings are trustworthy or believable — is essential to the research process. One aspect of credibility is repeatability, which includes assessing whether consistent results are obtained when using new data to answer the same question (replicability), when repeating the original analyses with the original data (reproducibility), or when conducting alternative analyses about the same question with the original data (robustness). These features of repeatability differ in the resources required to investigate them, and it is unknown how they relate with one another and with other features of credibility. We investigated relationships among credibility measures in a stratified random sample of claims made across the social and behavioral sciences. Measures of repeatability were modestly correlated with each other (r’s = 0.30, -0.04, -0.23) though the correlation between robustness and reproducibility is likely misestimated because selecting claims for robustness testing was partly contingent on reproducibility success. Replicability and human and machine predictions of replicability were modestly correlated (Median r = 0.23; Range = -0.10 to 0.47). Though estimated with substantial uncertainty in some cases, no discipline showed consistently higher repeatability than other disciplines across measures. For example, Education had the highest replicability estimate (0.63, 95% CI [.32 - .86]) and the lowest reproducibility estimate (0.25, 95% CI [.25, 95% CI [.06 - .38]), whereas Economics had the lowest replicability estimate (0.43, 95% CI [.28 - .64]) and nearly the highest reproducibility estimate (0.70, 95% CI [.56 - .85]). Repeatability measures were modestly and heterogeneously associated with other potential indicators of credibility (Median |r| = 0.08; Range = 0.01 to 0.55). Credibility assessment is multidimensional with substantial opportunity for innovation and validation of its measurement.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in MetaArXiv
Open AccessAssessments of Credibility in the Social and Behavioral Sciences
Credibility assessment — determining whether research findings are trustworthy or believable — is essential to the research process. One aspect of credibility is repeatability, which includes assessing whether consistent results are obtained when using new data to answer the same question (replicability), when repeating the original analyses with the original data (reproducibility), or when conducting alternative analyses about the same question with the original data (robustness). These features of repeatability differ in the resources required to investigate them, and it is unknown how they relate with one another and with other features of credibility. We investigated relationships among credibility measures in a stratified random sample of claims made across the social and behavioral sciences. Measures of repeatability were modestly correlated with each other (r’s = 0.30, -0.04, -0.23) though the correlation between robustness and reproducibility is likely misestimated because selecting claims for robustness testing was partly contingent on reproducibility success. Replicability and human and machine predictions of replicability were modestly correlated (Median r = 0.23; Range = -0.10 to 0.47). Though estimated with substantial uncertainty in some cases, no discipline showed consistently higher repeatability than other disciplines across measures. For example, Education had the highest replicability estimate (0.63, 95% CI [.32 - .86]) and the lowest reproducibility estimate (0.25, 95% CI [.25, 95% CI [.06 - .38]), whereas Economics had the lowest replicability estimate (0.43, 95% CI [.28 - .64]) and nearly the highest reproducibility estimate (0.70, 95% CI [.56 - .85]). Repeatability measures were modestly and heterogeneously associated with other potential indicators of credibility (Median |r| = 0.08; Range = 0.01 to 0.55). Credibility assessment is multidimensional with substantial opportunity for innovation and validation of its measurement.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 94-146
Rationality and Quantitative Reasoning Using the MCL Framework
This chapter uses the multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework to look at the very broad topic of quantitative reasoning, which includes two sharply contrasting theoretical viewpoints. In contrast to the relatively brief examples in Chapter 4, this is a challenging situation that shows how the MCL framework can be used as a common reference to usefully structure, understand, and equitably evaluate a complex body of research and ideas. The MCL framework also fosters the identification of gaps and conflicts in knowledge that highlight opportunities for key further research. The topic of quantitative reasoning reaches into broader issues of how to define and understand human rationality, and two underlying views on rationality (constrained maximization and extended adaptations) lead to two different models of quantitative reasoning (constrained maximization and expanded adaptations views). These two views are often contrasted against each other not just in quantitative reasoning generally, but in the specific topic of Bayesian reasoning. The resulting dual-process and favored formats models of Bayesian reasoning are systematically compared at the intentional level (theoretical and phylogenetic evidence), at the algorithmic level (psychological, developmental, cross-cultural, ancestral environments, and medical lines of evidence), and at the biological level (physiological and genetic evidence).
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 94-146
Rationality and Quantitative Reasoning Using the MCL Framework
This chapter uses the multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework to look at the very broad topic of quantitative reasoning, which includes two sharply contrasting theoretical viewpoints. In contrast to the relatively brief examples in Chapter 4, this is a challenging situation that shows how the MCL framework can be used as a common reference to usefully structure, understand, and equitably evaluate a complex body of research and ideas. The MCL framework also fosters the identification of gaps and conflicts in knowledge that highlight opportunities for key further research. The topic of quantitative reasoning reaches into broader issues of how to define and understand human rationality, and two underlying views on rationality (constrained maximization and extended adaptations) lead to two different models of quantitative reasoning (constrained maximization and expanded adaptations views). These two views are often contrasted against each other not just in quantitative reasoning generally, but in the specific topic of Bayesian reasoning. The resulting dual-process and favored formats models of Bayesian reasoning are systematically compared at the intentional level (theoretical and phylogenetic evidence), at the algorithmic level (psychological, developmental, cross-cultural, ancestral environments, and medical lines of evidence), and at the biological level (physiological and genetic evidence).
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 81-93
Quick Illustrative Examples of the MCL Framework
The multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework presented in Chapter 1 and discussed in Chapters 2–3 is meant to be a practical, working framework. This chapter has examples of how the framework can be used across a range of contexts. First, the MCL framework is used to organize and structure research on a broad topic that has a lot of existing evidence in many areas (human language). The MCL framework is then used to organize and structure a much more specific topic (learned taste aversion), to show that a broad topic is not necessary. A third example is terror management, which is a much more theory-driven topic, with a very different pattern of evidentiary support. Across all these examples, the framework also helps to more clearly reveal connections across fields, gaps, and conflicts in research (which are opportunities for further work). Further examples of the converging evidence approach in the literature are also noted. Finally, the examples in this chapter help to illustrate and clarify the relationship between topics and theories that are embedded in the MCL framework.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 81-93
Quick Illustrative Examples of the MCL Framework
The multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework presented in Chapter 1 and discussed in Chapters 2–3 is meant to be a practical, working framework. This chapter has examples of how the framework can be used across a range of contexts. First, the MCL framework is used to organize and structure research on a broad topic that has a lot of existing evidence in many areas (human language). The MCL framework is then used to organize and structure a much more specific topic (learned taste aversion), to show that a broad topic is not necessary. A third example is terror management, which is a much more theory-driven topic, with a very different pattern of evidentiary support. Across all these examples, the framework also helps to more clearly reveal connections across fields, gaps, and conflicts in research (which are opportunities for further work). Further examples of the converging evidence approach in the literature are also noted. Finally, the examples in this chapter help to illustrate and clarify the relationship between topics and theories that are embedded in the MCL framework.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-19
A Quick Guide to Multi-Level Converging Lines of Evidence
How can the behavioral sciences make better scientific progress? Unlike the physical sciences, which have largely become integrated and mutually consistent, the behavioral sciences too often operate in relative isolation from each other. This isolation can breed inconsistencies and contradictions. At the same time, the topics in the behavioral sciences are more complicated than physical objects, which means that an integrated understanding of these sciences needs to reflect that complexity. This chapter presents a framework for behavioral sciences that incorporates multiple, independent, and converging lines of evidence (MCL) that come into play at different levels of explanation. This MCL framework integrates previous models for converging evidence and levels of analysis, sharpening their focus onto the behavioral sciences. This framework is useful for understanding and evaluating research topics, but it is particularly useful for generating important and impactful research hypotheses-hypotheses that can push for stronger behavioral sciences integration and (when necessary) incite scientific revolutions.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-19
A Quick Guide to Multi-Level Converging Lines of Evidence
How can the behavioral sciences make better scientific progress? Unlike the physical sciences, which have largely become integrated and mutually consistent, the behavioral sciences too often operate in relative isolation from each other. This isolation can breed inconsistencies and contradictions. At the same time, the topics in the behavioral sciences are more complicated than physical objects, which means that an integrated understanding of these sciences needs to reflect that complexity. This chapter presents a framework for behavioral sciences that incorporates multiple, independent, and converging lines of evidence (MCL) that come into play at different levels of explanation. This MCL framework integrates previous models for converging evidence and levels of analysis, sharpening their focus onto the behavioral sciences. This framework is useful for understanding and evaluating research topics, but it is particularly useful for generating important and impactful research hypotheses-hypotheses that can push for stronger behavioral sciences integration and (when necessary) incite scientific revolutions.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Integrating Converging Evidence in Behavioral Sciences
Integrating Converging Evidence in Behavioral Sciences presents a fresh approach to understanding the landscape of scientific research, particularly within the behavioral sciences. By examining the needs for consistency and coherence across different scientific disciplines, this book offers readers a practical framework for evaluating and advancing their research topics. Through a comprehensive overview of established frameworks such as Marr’s computational framework and Tinbergen’s four questions, the book introduces a novel convergence framework specifically tailored to the behavioral sciences. This approach enables a more integrated view of scientific theories and knowledge, empowers researchers to pinpoint areas of high impact, and helps them to recognize potential revolutions in the field. The book serves a dual purpose: As a rubric for students and early-career researchers to grasp and navigate their research topics, and also as a resource for more advanced researchers seeking to delve into deeper issues and apply the framework across different contexts. This book is an essential guide for anyone interested in harmonizing scientific perspectives, developing more robust and interconnected fields of research, and potentially paving the way for groundbreaking discoveries.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Integrating Converging Evidence in Behavioral Sciences
Integrating Converging Evidence in Behavioral Sciences presents a fresh approach to understanding the landscape of scientific research, particularly within the behavioral sciences. By examining the needs for consistency and coherence across different scientific disciplines, this book offers readers a practical framework for evaluating and advancing their research topics. Through a comprehensive overview of established frameworks such as Marr’s computational framework and Tinbergen’s four questions, the book introduces a novel convergence framework specifically tailored to the behavioral sciences. This approach enables a more integrated view of scientific theories and knowledge, empowers researchers to pinpoint areas of high impact, and helps them to recognize potential revolutions in the field. The book serves a dual purpose: As a rubric for students and early-career researchers to grasp and navigate their research topics, and also as a resource for more advanced researchers seeking to delve into deeper issues and apply the framework across different contexts. This book is an essential guide for anyone interested in harmonizing scientific perspectives, developing more robust and interconnected fields of research, and potentially paving the way for groundbreaking discoveries.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 48-80
Concerns, Digressions, and Extensions of the MCL Framework
Chapter 1 presented the multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework for the behavioral sciences, and Chapter 2 reviewed the historical and philosophical backgrounds for that framework. This chapter looks forward to topics that the MCL framework can raise regarding particular aspects and in general. Some of these topics are about concerns or obstacles that the MCL framework may face: Inertia in research practices, or the idea of parsimony in explanations, or even the practical difficulty of doing fully interdisciplinary research. Another set of topics in this chapter are about the specific design and elements within the MCL framework (How many levels of explanation should there be? How many lines of evidence? Can one summarize framework results with an overall score?). Finally, there are topics that look forward to the implications of the MCL framework when used-how it really can generate better hypotheses and improve research replicability in the behavioral sciences, and how resistant it is to manipulation.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 48-80
Concerns, Digressions, and Extensions of the MCL Framework
Chapter 1 presented the multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework for the behavioral sciences, and Chapter 2 reviewed the historical and philosophical backgrounds for that framework. This chapter looks forward to topics that the MCL framework can raise regarding particular aspects and in general. Some of these topics are about concerns or obstacles that the MCL framework may face: Inertia in research practices, or the idea of parsimony in explanations, or even the practical difficulty of doing fully interdisciplinary research. Another set of topics in this chapter are about the specific design and elements within the MCL framework (How many levels of explanation should there be? How many lines of evidence? Can one summarize framework results with an overall score?). Finally, there are topics that look forward to the implications of the MCL framework when used-how it really can generate better hypotheses and improve research replicability in the behavioral sciences, and how resistant it is to manipulation.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 20-47
Historical and Philosophical Background of the MCL Framework
Chapter 1 presented a multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework for the behavioral sciences, and this chapter goes into some of the deeper historical and philosophical backgrounds of that framework. This MCL framework combines the ideas of convergence and consistency, which both have long but largely separate histories. On the one hand, multiple, independent lines of evidence that converge on the same conclusion are often used as a way to establish truth. On the other hand, it has long been recognized that full understandings of phenomena require different levels of explanation that are mutually consistent with one another. The MCL framework integrates these ideas, specifically for the analysis and understanding of human cognitive/behavioral traits. This chapter also explores the MCL framework’s position relative to prior scientific integration frameworks and some philosophy of science topics that are relevant to the framework (realism as a basic stance in science, consistency versus reductionistic unity of sciences, degrees of modularity in mental architecture, consciousness, and free will).
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 20-47
Historical and Philosophical Background of the MCL Framework
Chapter 1 presented a multi-level converging lines of evidence (MCL) framework for the behavioral sciences, and this chapter goes into some of the deeper historical and philosophical backgrounds of that framework. This MCL framework combines the ideas of convergence and consistency, which both have long but largely separate histories. On the one hand, multiple, independent lines of evidence that converge on the same conclusion are often used as a way to establish truth. On the other hand, it has long been recognized that full understandings of phenomena require different levels of explanation that are mutually consistent with one another. The MCL framework integrates these ideas, specifically for the analysis and understanding of human cognitive/behavioral traits. This chapter also explores the MCL framework’s position relative to prior scientific integration frameworks and some philosophy of science topics that are relevant to the framework (realism as a basic stance in science, consistency versus reductionistic unity of sciences, degrees of modularity in mental architecture, consciousness, and free will).