Beyond the Fact of Disagreement? The Epistemic Turn in Deliberative Democracy
Top Cited Papers
- 4 May 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Social Epistemology
- Vol. 31 (3) , 277-295
Abstract
This paper takes stock of a recent but growing movement within the field of deliberative democracy, which normatively argues for the epistemic dimension of democratic authority and positively defends the truth-tracking properties of democratic procedures. Authors within that movement call themselves epistemic democrats, hence the recognition by many of an ‘epistemic turn’ in democratic theory. The paper argues that this turn is a desirable direction in which the field ought to evolve, taking it beyond the ‘fact of disagreement’ that had previously blocked the conceptual road to acknowledging more than intrinsic properties to democratic decision procedures. The paper shows how two authors in particular – Joshua Cohen and David Estlund – have successfully lifted the Rawlsian requirement of epistemic abstinence and defends epistemic democrats and the implications of the epistemic turn in democratic theory against various misconceptions.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Deliberation, Participation, and Democratic Legitimacy: Should Deliberative Mini‐publics Shape Public Policy?Journal of Political Philosophy, 2014
- Disagreement and epistemic arguments for democracyPolitics, Philosophy & Economics, 2013
- The epistemic turn of critical theory: implications for deliberative politics and policy-makingCritical Policy Studies, 2010
- The Epistemology of DemocracyEpisteme, 2006
- Measuring Political Deliberation: A Discourse Quality IndexComparative European Politics, 2003
- Five Arguments for Deliberative DemocracyPolitical Studies, 2000
- The Insularity of the Reasonable: Why Political Liberalism Must Admit the TruthEthics, 1998
- Political Liberalism: Reply to HabermasThe Journal of Philosophy, 1995
- The Idea Of An Overlapping ConsensusOxford Journal of Legal Studies, 1987
- An Epistemic Conception of DemocracyEthics, 1986