Short-term quality of life comparison of laparoscopic, open, and robotic incisional hernia repairs
- 27 July 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Surgical Endoscopy
- Vol. 35 (6) , 2781-2788
Abstract
Background Outcomes of incisional hernia repair (IHR) include recurrence and quality of life (QOL). Operative approaches include laparoscopic, open, and robotic approaches. Data regarding comparative QOL outcomes among these repair types are unknown. Our study evaluates quality of life after three approaches to IHR. Study design Patients undergoing open (OHR), laparoscopic (LIHR), and robotic extra-peritoneal (RIHR) at a single institution from 2009 to 2019 were reviewed from a prospectively managed quality database. Short-term QOL was compared among the three procedures using the Surgical Outcomes Measurement System (SOMS) and Carolinas Comfort Scale (CCS), objective pain scores and postoperative narcotic use. Data regarding length of stay (LOS), emergency department (ED) visits, readmission, reoperations and surgical site infection (SSI) were also collected. Results A total of 795 patients undergoing IHR were analyzed (418 open, 300 laparoscopic and 77 robotic). Patient were similar in age, gender and co-morbidities. LIHR patients had higher BMI and RIHR patients had larger hernia and mesh size. LOS was longer and rate of SSI was higher for OIHR compared to laparoscopic and RIHR. Patients undergoing LIHR reported increased narcotic use, Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and CCS pain scores compared to open and robotic repair. Return to daily activity was 4 days shorter for robotic than open and laparoscopic repair; ED visits, readmissions, reoperations, and other QOL domains were similar. Conclusion Our data suggests that short-term quality of life after robotic extra-peritoneal IHR is improved compared to open and laparoscopic repair. Additional follow up is required to determine differences in long-term QOL after IHR.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- A direct comparison of robotic and laparoscopic hernia repair: patient-reported outcomes and cost analysisHernia, 2019
- Incisional Hernia Repair Minimally Invasive ApproachesSurgical Clinics of North America, 2018
- Carolinas Comfort Scale as a Measure of Hernia Repair Quality of LifeAnnals of Surgery, 2018
- A nationwide evaluation of robotic ventral hernia surgeryThe American Journal of Surgery, 2017
- Robotic ventral hernia repair is not superior to laparoscopic: a national database reviewSurgical Endoscopy, 2017
- Current perspectives in robotic hernia repairRobotic Surgery: Research and Reviews, 2017
- Standard laparoscopic versus robotic retromuscular ventral hernia repairSurgical Endoscopy, 2016
- The Surgical Outcomes Measurement System Is a Superior Measure of Patient-Centered Outcomes after Hernia RepairJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2015
- A systematic review of laparoscopic versus open abdominal incisional hernia repair, with meta-analysis of randomized controlled trialsInternational Journal of Surgery, 2015
- Comparison of Generic Versus Specific Quality-of-Life Scales for Mesh Hernia RepairsJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2008