Corroboration
Authors:
- Georgi GardinerGGGeorgi Gardiner
- Lewis RossLRLewis Ross
- Miguel EglerMEMiguel Egler
- Lisa BastianLBLisa Bastian
- 1 April 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of Illinois Press in American Philosophical Quarterly
- Vol. 60 (2) , 131-148
Abstract
Corroborating evidence supports a proposition that is already supported by other initial evidence. It bolsters or confirms the original body of evidence. Corroboration has striking psychological and epistemic force: It potently affects how people do and should assess the target proposition. This essay investigates the distinctive powers of corroborating evidence. Corroboration does not simply increase the quantifiable probability of the adjudicated claim. Drawing on the relevant alternatives framework, I argue that corroboration winnows remaining uneliminated error possibilities. This illuminates the independence, weight, and non-fungibility of corroborating evidence. I compare corroborating evidence to prudential safeguards, like fire doors, that forfend against non-epistemic harms. I thereby sketch a general, non-quantificational model of risk management. Finally, I turn to legal corroboration requirements and the epistemic significance of corroboration for legal proof.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Lottery judgments: A philosophical and experimental studyPhilosophical Psychology, 2017
- Between Probability and Certainty2016
- RiskMetaphilosophy, 2015
- Why Explanatoriness Is Evidentially RelevantThought: A Journal of Philosophy, 2014
- What Else Justification Could Be1Noûs, 2010
- Subject‐Sensitive Invariantism and the Knowledge Norm for Practical ReasoningNoûs, 2008
- EXPLORING THE PROOF PARADOXESLegal Theory, 2008
- How Probabilities Reflect EvidencePhilosophical Perspectives, 2005
- Jurors' use of naked statistical evidence: Exploring bases and implications of the Wells effect.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1999
- Elusive knowledgeAustralasian Journal of Philosophy, 1996