Devolving Dobbs: Abortion Politics and the Legitimacy of State High Courts
Top Cited Papers
- 27 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Research Quarterly
Abstract
Scholars have come to understand that the state supreme courts play a vital role in American politics, a conclusion driven home by the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent ruling that abortion rights must be fought out in the individual states. At the same time, little research has ever focused on how the mass publics in the states view their high courts, and especially on whether people are willing to extend those institutions legitimacy. Our purpose in this article is to first introduce new measures of the institutional legitimacy of the 50-state supreme courts (based on representative samples in each state) as of the close of 2023. After validating the measure, we present the results of 50 experiments (one in each state) concerning how an abortion-rights ruling, whether liked or disliked, might affect attitudes toward the state high courts. Informed by a theory of attitude updating, we find that specific support attitudes do get altered, but diffuse support attitudes do not. Finally, we consider the question of how the Dobbs context might be replicated in the American states, concluding that the state high courts are unlikely to make counter-majoritarian rulings.Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do the Effects of Unpopular Supreme Court Rulings Linger? The Dobbs Decision Rescinding Abortion RightsAmerican Political Science Review, 2024
- Substantive and Political Learning among the US States: Abortion Policy Diffusion, 1993–2016State Politics & Policy Quarterly, 2022
- A decade-long longitudinal survey shows that the Supreme Court is now much more conservative than the publicProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2022
- Voter Response to Salient Judicial Decisions in Retention ElectionsLaw & Social Inquiry, 2019
- The Supreme Court, the Media, and Public Opinion: Comparing Experimental and Observational MethodsThe Journal of Legal Studies, 2016
- Legitimacy Is for Losers: The Interconnections of Institutional Legitimacy, Performance Evaluations, and the Symbols of Judicial Authority2015
- Campaign Support, Conflicts of Interest, and Judicial Impartiality: Can Recusals Rescue the Legitimacy of Courts?The Journal of Politics, 2012
- Patterns of Newspaper Reporting on State Supreme CourtsJustice System Journal, 2010
- “New-Style” Judicial Campaigns and the Legitimacy of State High CourtsThe Journal of Politics, 2009
- Confidence in the courts: A comparison of users and non‐usersBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2001