JGJames L. Gibson

James L. Gibson

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


James L. Gibson has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Withholding One's Political Views: When, Why, and On What?

    by James L Gibson

    Scholarly interest in the unwillingness of people to express their political views has ballooned of late, across the world. Still, many details of when, why, and on what people self-censor remain unknown. In this largely exploratory analysis, using 2025 survey data from the United States, I pursue four objectives. First, I document the extremely high levels of self-censorship in the contemporary United States. Then I analyze the varied contexts in which people withhold their views, followed by an analysis of why they say they are reluctant to express themselves. In the most important part of my article, I examine the issues on which people are most likely to withhold their views. Distinguishing between expressed public opinion and true public opinion, I then show that on many issues self-censorship results in no ideological bias in expressed views, but on some issues—the Israeli war with Hamas, as the best example—considerable bias exists (true opinion differs from expressed opinion). I conclude with concerns about the deleterious effects of self-censorship on political discussions and deliberations in America.

  • Supporting Violence in a Violent Land: Condonation of Political Violence in South Africa

    by James L. Gibson, Amanda Gouws

    Research on public support for political violence has focused on three types of support: violence in the abstract, in the context of specific, contextualized events, and behavioral support. Most research uses abstract measures to indicate support, more limited research focuses on attitudes toward actual violent events, and little research addresses behavioral support. In this analysis, we examine the interrelationships of these three types of measures, based on a 2024 survey in a South African province with a long and recent history of widespread political violence. We draw three specific conclusions from our analyses: abstract attitudes are not entirely irrelevant, but some indicators are more useful than others. Abstract attitudes have some value for predicting how people judge realistic acts of political violence, just as these attitudes are to some degree connected to actual violent behavior. Our most important overall conclusion is that much more attention must be paid to measurement issues if scholars want valid and reliable evidence of popular support for political violence.

  • Infelicitous Political Talk: Disparaging Institutions and Support for Democracy

    by James L. Gibson, Michael J. Nelson

    Infelicitous political talk is now a routine feature of American politics, with scholars debating the extent to which it meaningfully shapes citizens’ democratic attitudes. We seek to contribute to this body of work by showing that the degree of inappropriateness of a criticism is continuous and subjective; that rhetorical denigration of democratic institutions is more likely to influence evaluations of the speaker than to erode broader commitments to democracy; and that criticisms that “cross the line” of appropriateness can create backlashes that actually wind up increasing support for democratic institutions and values. Using an experiment embedded in a national survey, we evaluate the effects of inappropriate attacks on the U.S. judiciary. Perceived rhetorical denigration does not weaken democratic values; instead, it produces a small but consistent backlash that slightly increases support for democratic institutions. Our various findings strongly challenge the assumption that rising infelicitous talk poses a serious threat to democratic stability in the U.S.

  • Race and Allegiance to the U.S. Supreme Court: Withering Institutional Support Among Black Americans in the Post- Dobbs Era

    by James L. Gibson

    Scholars have been quick to try to assess the consequences of the U.S. Supreme Court’s monumental ruling abrogating abortion rights in the U.S. ( Dobbs ), with several studies showing that the decision seems to have ushered in a new era of significantly diminished support for the Court. But important issues remain unresolved. Perhaps most important, how have racial minorities, especially African Americans, been affected by the Court’s ruling? Based on an unusually large and representative subsample of African Americans, I discover that a substantial proportion of Black people extend remarkably little legitimacy to the U.S. Supreme Court after Dobbs . Some of the difference between Black and White people seems to be associated with the abortion ruling (as I carefully document), but another portion has to do with much lower levels of support of the Court before Dobbs , and with weaker attachments to legitimacy-enhancing democratic values. I conclude that studies of the attitudes and values of minorities, while important in and of themselves, can also help researchers understand more general processes by which citizens update their institutional attitudes.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Institutional Structures and Judicial Legitimacy

    by Michael J. Nelson, James L. Gibson

    Despite high-profile arguments about the negative consequences of judicial elections for judicial legitimacy, empirical evidence is ambiguous, at best. Drawing on more than 28,000 survey responses, representative at the state level, we find no evidence that elected courts are less legitimate than appointed courts. To further explore this finding, we draw upon a survey of Wisconsin, a state that has experienced a large amount of politicized judicial campaigning. We demonstrate that citizens expect this type of activity in their elections, even though they say they dislike it. Then, we present new evidence on the causal effects of campaign activity on attitudes toward courts in this state. We demonstrate that, though citizens may believe that courts selected through expensive and negative elections are less fair, there is no evidence that they find elected courts to be less legitimate or worthy of compliance.


  • Open Access

    Reluctance to Speak Your Mind: Changing Perceptions of the Costs of Speaking Out Among Black and White Americans

    by James L. Gibson

    Scholarly interest in whether ordinary people are willing to freely express their views on political matters has been piqued in recent times, owing in part to concerns about the consequences of political polarization. For instance, new evidence suggests a massive increase over the last several decades in self-censorship by both the American and German people. This article expands existing research on reluctance to speak out, with a focus on using US survey data on the stark and changing inter-racial and generational differences in perceived political freedom, and by documenting factors not related to self-censorship (such as individual-level polarization, gender, social class, etc.). I conclude with some speculation about the consequences of the loss of perceived freedom of speech for the quality of democracy.


  • Top Cited Papers

    Devolving Dobbs: Abortion Politics and the Legitimacy of State High Courts

    by James L. Gibson, Michael J. Nelson

    Scholars have come to understand that the state supreme courts play a vital role in American politics, a conclusion driven home by the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent ruling that abortion rights must be fought out in the individual states. At the same time, little research has ever focused on how the mass publics in the states view their high courts, and especially on whether people are willing to extend those institutions legitimacy. Our purpose in this article is to first introduce new measures of the institutional legitimacy of the 50-state supreme courts (based on representative samples in each state) as of the close of 2023. After validating the measure, we present the results of 50 experiments (one in each state) concerning how an abortion-rights ruling, whether liked or disliked, might affect attitudes toward the state high courts. Informed by a theory of attitude updating, we find that specific support attitudes do get altered, but diffuse support attitudes do not. Finally, we consider the question of how the Dobbs context might be replicated in the American states, concluding that the state high courts are unlikely to make counter-majoritarian rulings.


  • Democracy's Destruction? Changing Perceptions of the Supreme Court, the Presidency, and the Senate after the 2020 Election

    by James L Gibson

    Did Trump and his Make America Great Again followers inflict damage on American political institutions via election denialism and the assault on the U.S. Capitol? Although most pundits and many scholars find this a question easy to answer in the affirmative, to date, little rigorous evidence on Trump's institutional consequences has been adduced. Based on surveys of representative samples of the American people in July 2020, December 2020, March 2021, and June 2021, this detailed analysis examines whether American political institutions lost legitimacy over the period from before the presidential election to well after it and whether any such loss is associated with acceptance of the “Big Lie” about the election and its aftermath. My highly contrarian conclusion is simple: try as they might (and did), Trump and his Republicans, in fact, did not succeed in undermining American national political institutions. The empirical evidence indicates that institutions seem to be more resilient than many have imagined, just as legitimacy theory would predict.


  • Justifying Political Violence: African American Attitudes Toward Protests Against Police Attacks on Black People

    by James L. Gibson

    Concern over the breadth of support for political violence is rising among scholars. However, important unanswered questions remain: First, are attitudes toward political violence, as commonly measured, too abstract to have any real-life meaning? Second, how do ever-present contextual factors shape judgments in the events in which violence materializes? Third, given that African Americans are so often on the receiving end of violence, how supportive are Black people of the use of political violence? Finally, what accounts for variability among Black people in attitudes toward violence—what role is played by experiences with unfair treatment by the police and in-group attachments and identities? Based on a nationally representative panel survey of African Americans, I provide empirical answers to each of these important questions. Black support for political violence is indeed connected to both identities and experiences, as well as to core values such as support for the rule of law.