The Analysis of Competing Hypotheses in Legal Proceedings
- 7 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Applied Cognitive Psychology
- Vol. 39 (5)
Abstract
The present study examined the potential benefit of the Analysis of Competing Hypotheses (ACH) method to reduce confirmation bias in legal proceedings. To this end, 222 law students participated in an online study and assessed an ambiguous homicide investigation. Participants were divided into three groups: control group, single‐hypothesis group, and ACH group. To assess the test–retest reliability of the ACH method, a follow‐up study with 30 participants was conducted. As no indication of confirmation bias was observed, the possible benefits of the ACH method as a debiasing method in legal proceedings could not be fully assessed. However, participants' confidence in their guilt assessment significantly increased when applying the ACH method. Simultaneously, exclusively examining the guilt‐hypothesis led to a focus on significantly more non‐diagnostic evidence. No other group differences emerged. Findings regarding the ACH method's temporal stability are mixed, highlighting the method's sensitivity to small changes in the evaluation process.Keywords
Funding Information
- Studienstiftung des Deutschen Volkes
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trust but verify: The biasing effects of witness opinions and background knowledge in workplace investigationsJournal of Safety Research, 2024
- Coherence of probability judgments from uncertain evidence: Does ACH help?Judgment and Decision Making, 2020
- Test of the analysis of competing hypotheses in legal decision‐makingApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2020
- The “analysis of competing hypotheses” in intelligence analysisApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2019
- Boosting intelligence analysts’ judgment accuracy: What works, what fails?Judgment and Decision Making, 2018
- Process standardization and error reduction: A revisit from a choice approachSafety Science, 2018
- The forensic confirmation bias: Problems, perspectives, and proposed solutions.Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 2013
- Let's find the evidence: an analogue study of confirmation bias in criminal investigationsJournal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling, 2010
- Motivational sources of confirmation bias in criminal investigations: the need for cognitive closureJournal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling, 2005
- Debiasing1982