RVRenate Volbert

Renate Volbert

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Renate Volbert has a total of 82 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Does trauma-focused psychotherapy alter pre-existing memories? A survey of German psychotherapists

    by Jonas Schemmel, Victoria Kertess, Renate Volbert

    How psychotherapy can affect patients’ memories has long been debated (Dodier et al., 2024; Lynn et al., 2023; Otgaar et al., 2019; Patihis et al., 2014). Much of this debate has focused on the nat...

  • Open Access

    Can Large Language Models Code Reality Criteria in Autobiographical Statements? Reliability and Validity of an Artificial Intelligence–Based Tool for Criteria-Based Content Analysis

    by Elsa Gewehr, Laureen Gräflich, Johannes Zimmermann, Renate Volbert

    Objective: Coding for Criteria-Based Content Analysis (CBCA) to differentiate fabricated from experience-based autobiographical statements is slow and depends on trained coders whose agreement is imperfect. We developed the large language model (LLM) based system CBC-AID and evaluate its reliability and validity in coding CBCA. Hypotheses: As preregistered, AI–human consistency is non-inferior to the interrater reliability of trained coders (H1: total score; H2: each criterion), and AI-based scores discriminate between experience-based and fabricated statements at least as well as human scores (H3: total score; H4: each criterion). Method: Two versions of an LLM-based coding tool (CBC-AID), a single-prompt and a multi-agent system, coded 957 transcripts from 399 persons in nine laboratory studies with human CBCA codings and known truth status. Bivariate Bayesian multilevel models estimated within-study correlations and standardized truth effects under global rating and weighted frequency. Results: AI–human correlations of the total scores (ρ = .53–.67) fell short of the benchmark of .66 in all four combinations of version and scoring scheme; Version 1 under global rating came closest (ρ = .67, 95% CrI [.62, .72]). The AI assigned higher scores than human coders (0.7–2.7 SD). Truth effects were similar for AI-based (δ = 0.17–0.32) and human coding (0.16–0.24; Δδ = −0.06 to 0.12); non-inferiority was supported for one of four combinations, and human coding itself discriminated weakly. Conclusions: LLM-based coding approximated but did not reach the consistency of trained coders and preserved their modest discriminative validity. It may serve as a traceable supplement to human coding in research; forensic use requires field validation and human oversight.

  • Open Access

    The analysis of competing hypotheses and expert witness testimony: Counteracting adversarial allegiance in witness credibility assessments?

    by Jana Otzipka, Renate Volbert

    Cognitive biases, such as adversarial allegiance, can compromise expert witness evaluations and contribute to wrongful convictions. Therefore, the application of debiasing strategies is essential. The Analysis of Competing Hypotheses (ACH) has been proposed as a potential method to reduce such bias, although empirical support remains limited. The present study investigated the effectiveness of the ACH method in mitigating adversarial allegiance in a sample of mock expert witnesses for credibility assessments. In an online experiment, 159 participants with prior knowledge in credibility assessments reviewed a summary of a child sexual abuse case. Before reviewing the case material, participants were randomly assigned to one of three retaining party conditions: defense, accessory prosecution, or court. Next, half of the participants were instructed to apply the ACH method which includes the systematic comparison of alternative hypotheses within a matrix. Meanwhile the control group was instructed to follow the standard approach in credibility assessments in Germany, which includes the evaluation and falsification of alternative hypotheses, albeit in a less structured way than the ACH method. Outcomes were assessed using credibility ratings and an Evidence Score, the latter reflecting the extent to which participants weighed evidence in favor of their retaining party or evaluated information more evenly. No significant differences emerged in credibility ratings across conditions. However, adversarial allegiance was evident in the Evidence Score: defense-retained participants emphasized evidence undermining the statement’s credibility more than those retained by the accessory prosecution. At the same time, the application of the ACH method did not significantly influence credibility ratings or evidence selection. Overall, these findings suggest that the ACH method may have limited utility as a debiasing strategy in the context of credibility assessments and underscore the challenges of mitigating bias in forensic decision-making.


  • Open Access

    Child Sexual Abuse Allegations in Child Custody, Child Visitation, and Child Protection Proceedings: A Scoping Review

    by Jonas Schemmel, Katharina Zell, Asne Senberg, Anna-Luisa Sahlfeld, Jana Otzipka, Renate Volbert, Jelena Zumbach-Basu

    Allegations of child sexual abuse (CSA) in family law cases, such as child custody, child visitation, and child protection proceedings, present complex and sensitive challenges for legal and psychological decision-making. This scoping review synthesizes key findings from 47 empirical studies examining the prevalence, substantiation, and legal consequences of CSA allegations as well as typical case characteristics in this context. The empirical literature falls into three main clusters: Canadian studies using large national datasets from the late 1990s and 2000s; Australian court-based studies primarily from the 2010s; and U.S. research spanning several decades with diverse methodologies. Overall, we found a mean CSA allegation prevalence of 8.9%, and indications that CSA allegations occur less frequently than allegations of other maltreatment types. Substantiation rates vary across studies but average around 43%, with only marginal evidence suggesting slightly lower substantiation when only custody and visitation disputes were analyzed. Deliberate false allegations are seemingly rare; most unsubstantiated claims appear to arise from genuine but mistaken concerns. Limited findings on legal consequences indicate that substantiated allegations usually lead to suspended contact between the accused parent and child. When allegations lack sufficient clarity, courts respond more variably, sometimes restricting contact despite non-substantiation. Significant research gaps remain, particularly regarding the timing and context of allegations, the association of substantiation with legal outcomes, and specific allegation constellations within families. Further empirical research, especially from European and non-Western jurisdictions, is essential to informing evidence-based, child-centered practice.

  • Open Access

    A European-wide survey of police officers’ beliefs and perceptions on suspect interviews

    by Jennifer Maria Schell-Leugers, Miet Vanderhallen, Glynis Bogaard, Sara Landstrom, Jaume Masip, Trond Myklebust, Renate Volbert, Veerle Nieuwkamp, Saul M. Kassin


  • Open Access

    Cognitions and Emotions about Child Sexual Abuse (CECSA): Development of a Self-Report Measure to Predict Interviewer Bias

    by Elsa Gewehr, Renate Volbert, Marie Merschhemke, Pekka Olavi Santtila, Simone Pülschen

    Interviewer bias fosters confirmatory reasoning and suggestive questioning when adults talk to children about abuse suspicions in investigative, child-protection, healthcare, or educational settings. We developed a self-report instrument on Cognitions and Emotions about Child Sexual Abuse (CECSA) that may predict individual propensity for interviewer bias. Three subscales, 23 items in total, were created in a sample of 801 humanities students via exploratory factor analysis and Ant Colony Optimization. The “Naïve Confidence” subscale reflects overestimating one's ability to recognize abused children and overestimating the accuracy of children’s abuse reports, the "Emotional Reactivity" subscale measures the intensity of one's emotional reactions towards the topic of child sexual abuse (CSA), and the "Justice System Distrust" subscale covers distrusting the justice system’s ability to prosecute CSA. The CECSA showed adequate model fit and good internal consistencies. Correlations with other self-report measures demonstrated convergent validity. All subscales predicted biased evaluations towards the abuse hypothesis in scenarios of children displaying unspecific behavioral problems. This indicates predictive validity of the CECSA to measure vulnerability for interviewer bias, although further validation effort is needed. Prospectively, the CECSA may be used to evaluate interviewer trainings or to assess training needs of professionals who talk to children about CSA suspicions.

  • The Analysis of Competing Hypotheses in Legal Proceedings

    by Jana Otzipka, Renate Volbert

    The present study examined the potential benefit of the Analysis of Competing Hypotheses (ACH) method to reduce confirmation bias in legal proceedings. To this end, 222 law students participated in an online study and assessed an ambiguous homicide investigation. Participants were divided into three groups: control group, single‐hypothesis group, and ACH group. To assess the test–retest reliability of the ACH method, a follow‐up study with 30 participants was conducted. As no indication of confirmation bias was observed, the possible benefits of the ACH method as a debiasing method in legal proceedings could not be fully assessed. However, participants' confidence in their guilt assessment significantly increased when applying the ACH method. Simultaneously, exclusively examining the guilt‐hypothesis led to a focus on significantly more non‐diagnostic evidence. No other group differences emerged. Findings regarding the ACH method's temporal stability are mixed, highlighting the method's sensitivity to small changes in the evaluation process.


  • Open Access

    Falsche Prämissen und eine vertane Chance – Replik auf die „Expertise“ zur Methode der forensischen Glaubhaftigkeitsbegutachtung (Fegert, Gerke, Kliemann, Pusch, Rixen & Sachser, 2024)

    by Renate Volbert, Nathalie Brackmann, Elsa Gewehr, Luise Greuel, Anja Kannegießer, Andreas Mokros, Michaela Pfundmair, Kristina Suchotzki, Jonas Schemmel

    Zusammenfassung: Im März 2024 erschien Die Methode der forensischen Glaubhaftigkeitsbegutachtung im deutschen Sprachraum – Ein interdisziplinäres Plädoyer für eine kritische Bestandsaufnahme zur Anwendung der sogenannten „Nullhypothese“ in unterschiedlichen Verfahrenskontexten (Fegert et al. 2024a), welche mit Mitteln der Unabhängigen Beauftragten für Fragen des sexuellen Kindesmissbrauchs (UBSKM) gefördert wurde. Dort wird argumentiert, die Glaubhaftigkeitsbegutachtung wecke wegen der Bezugnahme auf das Nullhypothesentesten den irreführenden Eindruck, es handele sich um ein quantitatives Vorgehen. In der Folge fordern die Autor*innen für das Strafverfahren eine Abkehr vom Nullhypothesentesten und stattdessen ein qualitatives Vorgehen unter Berücksichtigung individueller Umstände und Voraussetzungen. Für familiengerichtliche Verfahren und für das Soziale Entschädigungsrecht fordern sie einen völligen Verzicht auf diesen Ansatz. Für das Soziale Entschädigungsrecht wird stattdessen eine Plausibilitätseinschätzung durch Personen in Heilberufen vorgeschlagen. Die Argumentation von Fegert et al. (2024a) basiert auf falschen Prämissen und ist ohne Bezug zu aussagepsychologischer Literatur: Allen einschlägigen Lehrbüchern ist zu entnehmen, dass eine Glaubhaftigkeitsbegutachtung aus einem qualitativen Vorgehen unter Berücksichtigung fall- und personenspezifischer Besonderheiten besteht. Lege artis durchgeführte Glaubhaftigkeitsbegutachtungen verfahren also bereits aktuell so wie in der vorgelegten Expertise gefordert; die diesbezügliche Kritik läuft damit ins Leere. Auch wenn der Begriff der Nullhypothese zu Missverständnissen geführt hat, besteht bezüglich der systematischen Prüfung von Alternativhypothesen zur Beurteilung der Glaubhaftigkeit einer Aussage international wissenschaftlicher Konsens. Die unterschiedlichen rechtlichen Rahmenbedingungen mit ihren jeweiligen Beweisschwellen sind dabei zu berücksichtigen. Im Fazit bleibt eine lege artis durchgeführte aussagepsychologische Begutachtung aktuell die beste Methode zur Beurteilung der Glaubhaftigkeit einer Aussage; wobei eine kontinuierliche wissenschaftliche Weiterentwicklung und Qualitätssicherung stets erforderlich ist.