Abstract
This chapter discusses classical music recordings through music critics’ writing. By presenting findings from a multi-layered, large-scale analysis of the content of published recording reviews (N = 965) from 1923 to 2018, the chapter focuses on expert critics’ listening and, essentially, their beliefs about what constitutes a great recorded performance. The analysis yielded a structured model that shows what critics write about and how they evaluate recorded performance. This model identified nine elements regularly discussed in reviews, four of which are unique to the record-product: ‘recorded sound’, ‘production process’, ‘package’, and ‘price’. Four main categories of value that a recording may possess emerged: ‘aesthetic’, ‘achievement’, ‘product’ (i.e. live impact and collectability), and ‘context-dependent’ value (including novelty and suitability). Analysis of this large corpus of reviews shows how the interplay of all elements and values shapes the unique identity of recordings as artworks distinct from live performances. Yet this unique aggregate nature of recordings is also challenged by current modes of music consumption that isolate single elements, possibly prompting critics and music creators to rethink the very nature of recorded performance and its value.