Elena Alessandri
Elena Alessandri has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Dawn C. Rose
Lucerne University of Applied Sciences & Arts
3 shared publications - Lorenz Kilchenmann
Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Lucerne, Switzerland
2 shared publications - Olivier Senn
Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Lucerne, Switzerland
2 shared publications Rafael Jerjen
School of Music
2 shared publicationsAntonio Baldassarre
School of Music, Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Lucerne, Switzerland
1 shared publication- Antonio Baldassarre
Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 15 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 67-84
Recorded performance reviewed
This chapter discusses classical music recordings through music critics’ writing. By presenting findings from a multi-layered, large-scale analysis of the content of published recording reviews (N = 965) from 1923 to 2018, the chapter focuses on expert critics’ listening and, essentially, their beliefs about what constitutes a great recorded performance. The analysis yielded a structured model that shows what critics write about and how they evaluate recorded performance. This model identified nine elements regularly discussed in reviews, four of which are unique to the record-product: ‘recorded sound’, ‘production process’, ‘package’, and ‘price’. Four main categories of value that a recording may possess emerged: ‘aesthetic’, ‘achievement’, ‘product’ (i.e. live impact and collectability), and ‘context-dependent’ value (including novelty and suitability). Analysis of this large corpus of reviews shows how the interplay of all elements and values shapes the unique identity of recordings as artworks distinct from live performances. Yet this unique aggregate nature of recordings is also challenged by current modes of music consumption that isolate single elements, possibly prompting critics and music creators to rethink the very nature of recorded performance and its value.
- 15 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 67-84
Recorded performance reviewed
This chapter discusses classical music recordings through music critics’ writing. By presenting findings from a multi-layered, large-scale analysis of the content of published recording reviews (N = 965) from 1923 to 2018, the chapter focuses on expert critics’ listening and, essentially, their beliefs about what constitutes a great recorded performance. The analysis yielded a structured model that shows what critics write about and how they evaluate recorded performance. This model identified nine elements regularly discussed in reviews, four of which are unique to the record-product: ‘recorded sound’, ‘production process’, ‘package’, and ‘price’. Four main categories of value that a recording may possess emerged: ‘aesthetic’, ‘achievement’, ‘product’ (i.e. live impact and collectability), and ‘context-dependent’ value (including novelty and suitability). Analysis of this large corpus of reviews shows how the interplay of all elements and values shapes the unique identity of recordings as artworks distinct from live performances. Yet this unique aggregate nature of recordings is also challenged by current modes of music consumption that isolate single elements, possibly prompting critics and music creators to rethink the very nature of recorded performance and its value.
- 1 March 2023
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance
- Vol. 49 (3) , 290-305
An SEM approach to validating the psychological model of musical groove.
In music psychology, the experience of wanting to move in response to music is commonly known as feeling the groove. According to the psychological model of musical groove by Senn et al., the causes for the urge to move are linked to the properties of the music itself, to the personal background of the listener, to the listening situation, and to feedback loops between body movement and cognition. The model formulates eight hypotheses stating that the music affects a listener's urge to move mediated through a variety of cognitive processes. This study develops a method based on structural equation modeling (SEM) to empirically test the model hypotheses. It evaluates five of the model hypotheses using data from an online listening experiment with 135 participants and 16 stylistically diverse musical stimuli (n = 2,160 observations). The SEM model had a good fit with the data (CFI = 0.958, RMSEA = 0.051) and explained a large proportion of the variance in the latent urge to move variable (R² = .737). Results show that music affects the urge to move mediated through listeners' experiences of energetic arousal, listening pleasure, and temporal regularity. The stimuli themselves showed direct effects on the urge to move that were not mediated through the hypothesized mediation pathways. This suggests that the model is incomplete. The current study demonstrates that the mediation structure of the psychological groove model can successfully be implemented using an SEM approach. The methodology may be adapted to investigate different repertoires, populations, and hypotheses in the future. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 March 2023
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance
- Vol. 49 (3) , 290-305
An SEM approach to validating the psychological model of musical groove.
In music psychology, the experience of wanting to move in response to music is commonly known as feeling the groove. According to the psychological model of musical groove by Senn et al., the causes for the urge to move are linked to the properties of the music itself, to the personal background of the listener, to the listening situation, and to feedback loops between body movement and cognition. The model formulates eight hypotheses stating that the music affects a listener's urge to move mediated through a variety of cognitive processes. This study develops a method based on structural equation modeling (SEM) to empirically test the model hypotheses. It evaluates five of the model hypotheses using data from an online listening experiment with 135 participants and 16 stylistically diverse musical stimuli (n = 2,160 observations). The SEM model had a good fit with the data (CFI = 0.958, RMSEA = 0.051) and explained a large proportion of the variance in the latent urge to move variable (R² = .737). Results show that music affects the urge to move mediated through listeners' experiences of energetic arousal, listening pleasure, and temporal regularity. The stimuli themselves showed direct effects on the urge to move that were not mediated through the hypothesized mediation pathways. This suggests that the model is incomplete. The current study demonstrates that the mediation structure of the psychological groove model can successfully be implemented using an SEM approach. The methodology may be adapted to investigate different repertoires, populations, and hypotheses in the future. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Music & Science
- Vol. 6
A Stimulus Set of 40 Popular Music Drum Patterns with Perceived Complexity Measures
This study presents an audio stimulus set of 40 drum patterns from Western popular music with empirical measurements of perceived complexity. The audio stimuli are meticulous reconstructions of drum patterns found in commercial recordings; they are based on careful transcriptions (carried out by professional musicians), drum stroke loudness information, and highly precise onset timing measurements. The 40 stimuli are a subset selected from a previously published larger corpus of reconstructed Western popular music drum patterns (Lucerne Groove Research Library). The patterns were selected according to two criteria: a) they only feature the bass drum, snare drum, and one or more cymbals, and b) they plausibly cover the complexity range of the corpus. Perceived stimulus complexity was measured in a listening experiment using a pairwise comparison design with 220 participants (4,400 trials). In each trial, participants were presented with two stimuli, and they stated which of the two sounded more complex to them. The comparison data then served to calculate complexity estimates using the Bradley–Terry probability model. The complexity estimates have an intuitive interpretation: they allow calculation of the probability that one pattern is considered more complex than another pattern in a pairwise comparison. To our knowledge, this is the first set of naturalistic music stimuli with meaningful perceived complexity estimates. The drum pattern stimuli and complexity measurements can be used for listening experiments in music psychology. The stimuli will further allow measures and models of drum pattern complexity to be assessed.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Music & Science
- Vol. 6
Open AccessA Stimulus Set of 40 Popular Music Drum Patterns with Perceived Complexity Measures
This study presents an audio stimulus set of 40 drum patterns from Western popular music with empirical measurements of perceived complexity. The audio stimuli are meticulous reconstructions of drum patterns found in commercial recordings; they are based on careful transcriptions (carried out by professional musicians), drum stroke loudness information, and highly precise onset timing measurements. The 40 stimuli are a subset selected from a previously published larger corpus of reconstructed Western popular music drum patterns (Lucerne Groove Research Library). The patterns were selected according to two criteria: a) they only feature the bass drum, snare drum, and one or more cymbals, and b) they plausibly cover the complexity range of the corpus. Perceived stimulus complexity was measured in a listening experiment using a pairwise comparison design with 220 participants (4,400 trials). In each trial, participants were presented with two stimuli, and they stated which of the two sounded more complex to them. The comparison data then served to calculate complexity estimates using the Bradley–Terry probability model. The complexity estimates have an intuitive interpretation: they allow calculation of the probability that one pattern is considered more complex than another pattern in a pairwise comparison. To our knowledge, this is the first set of naturalistic music stimuli with meaningful perceived complexity estimates. The drum pattern stimuli and complexity measurements can be used for listening experiments in music psychology. The stimuli will further allow measures and models of drum pattern complexity to be assessed.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Music & Science
- Vol. 3
Consumers on Critique: A Survey of Classical Music Listeners’ Engagement with Professional Music Reviews
Music criticism has a long tradition as a leading agent in the classical music discourse. However, some people question its function in the contemporary music market. We explored the topicality of classical music critique by asking: Who reads professional reviews today? And what do readers expect from review? Through an online survey (English/German), we profiled the listening habits of classical music listeners (N = 1200) and their engagement with professional reviews. Our participants were more actively engaged with music, but contrary to the ‘highbrow’ stereotype, not more highly musically trained than the general population. They consumed music and opinion sources in a variety of ways. Approximately two-thirds (n = 741) of the participants had recently engaged with professional reviews, which were perceived as the most useful form of opinion, followed by short written commentaries and, lastly, ratings. A multiple logistic regression model suggested that the typical consumer of professional music critique was older with higher levels of musical engagement and education, had a higher inclination to purchase music and lower usage of streaming services, and had a preference for detailed reviews from traditional sources (e.g. newspapers). According to review readers, reviews should cover a variety of topics and offer evaluations underpinned with reasons. Reviewers should be constructive, open-minded, respectful, and well informed; their professional background was less relevant. Professional reviews should not necessarily provide a recommendation on what to buy, but rather guide listeners’ musical appreciation and understanding. Professional criticism still has an audience, although more so among older, musically educated listeners. Critics need to explore various channels in order to connect to a new generation of classical music listeners.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Music & Science
- Vol. 3
Open AccessConsumers on Critique: A Survey of Classical Music Listeners’ Engagement with Professional Music Reviews
Music criticism has a long tradition as a leading agent in the classical music discourse. However, some people question its function in the contemporary music market. We explored the topicality of classical music critique by asking: Who reads professional reviews today? And what do readers expect from review? Through an online survey (English/German), we profiled the listening habits of classical music listeners (N = 1200) and their engagement with professional reviews. Our participants were more actively engaged with music, but contrary to the ‘highbrow’ stereotype, not more highly musically trained than the general population. They consumed music and opinion sources in a variety of ways. Approximately two-thirds (n = 741) of the participants had recently engaged with professional reviews, which were perceived as the most useful form of opinion, followed by short written commentaries and, lastly, ratings. A multiple logistic regression model suggested that the typical consumer of professional music critique was older with higher levels of musical engagement and education, had a higher inclination to purchase music and lower usage of streaming services, and had a preference for detailed reviews from traditional sources (e.g. newspapers). According to review readers, reviews should cover a variety of topics and offer evaluations underpinned with reasons. Reviewers should be constructive, open-minded, respectful, and well informed; their professional background was less relevant. Professional reviews should not necessarily provide a recommendation on what to buy, but rather guide listeners’ musical appreciation and understanding. Professional criticism still has an audience, although more so among older, musically educated listeners. Critics need to explore various channels in order to connect to a new generation of classical music listeners.
- 3 July 2014
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 22-33
The Notion of Expression in Music Criticism
Expression is arguably one of the most common and important terms in musical discourse, used as a measure of the aesthetic value of musical performance. But what does it mean for a performance to be expressive or for a performer to play expressively? The difficulty of this question resides in the complexity of the expression phenomenon and in the ambiguity that the word “express” and its correlates can bring to the expression discourses shared in different contexts (e.g. typical listeners, musicians, researchers). This chapter discusses some of the main issues related to the ambiguous usage of the term “expression” in musical parlance through an examination of music critics’ reviews of Beethoven’s 32 piano sonatas. It attempts to clarify what critics mean—or seem to mean—when they talk of expression in music, and how this notion relates to their critical judgements.
- 3 July 2014
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 22-33
The Notion of Expression in Music Criticism
Expression is arguably one of the most common and important terms in musical discourse, used as a measure of the aesthetic value of musical performance. But what does it mean for a performance to be expressive or for a performer to play expressively? The difficulty of this question resides in the complexity of the expression phenomenon and in the ambiguity that the word “express” and its correlates can bring to the expression discourses shared in different contexts (e.g. typical listeners, musicians, researchers). This chapter discusses some of the main issues related to the ambiguous usage of the term “expression” in musical parlance through an examination of music critics’ reviews of Beethoven’s 32 piano sonatas. It attempts to clarify what critics mean—or seem to mean—when they talk of expression in music, and how this notion relates to their critical judgements.