Individual Importance Weighting of Domain Satisfaction Ratings does Not Increase Validity
Open Access
- 1 January 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of California Press in Collabra: Psychology
- Vol. 4 (1)
Abstract
Bottom-up models of life satisfaction are based on the assumption that individuals judge the overall quality of their lives by aggregating information across various life domains, such as health, family, and income. This aggregation supposedly involves a weighting procedure because individuals care about different parts of their lives to varying degrees. Thus, composite measures of well-being should be more accurate if domain satisfaction scores are weighted by the importance that respondents assign to the respective domains. Previous studies have arrived at mixed conclusions about whether such a procedure actually works. In the present study, importance weighting was investigated in the Panel Study of Income Dynamics (PSID; N = 5,049). Both weighted composite scores and moderated regression analyses converged in producing the conclusion that individual importance weights did not result in higher correlations with the outcome variable, a global measure of life satisfaction. By contrast, using weights that vary normatively across domains (e.g., assigning a larger weight to family satisfaction than to housing satisfaction for all respondents) significantly increased the correlation with global life satisfaction (although incremental validity was rather humble). These results converge with findings from other fields such as self-concept research, where evidence for individual importance weighting seems elusive as best.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Theory and Validity of Life Satisfaction ScalesSocial Indicators Research, 2012
- The Elusive Importance Effect: More Failure for the Jamesian Perspective on the Importance of Importance in Shaping Self‐EsteemJournal of Personality, 2008
- The Perils of PartiallingAssessment, 2006
- Would You Be Happier If You Were Richer? A Focusing IllusionScience, 2006
- Importance Ratings and Weighting: Old Concerns and New PerspectivesInternational Journal of Testing, 2005
- The influence of chronically and temporarily accessible information on life satisfaction judgments.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2005
- Cross-Cultural Variations in Predictors of Life Satisfaction: Perspectives from Needs and ValuesPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 1999
- Value as a Moderator in Subjective Well‐BeingJournal of Personality, 1999
- Age as a Moderator of the Determinants of Life SatisfactionResearch on Aging, 1985
- Tests for comparing elements of a correlation matrix.Psychological Bulletin, 1980