“Hitting the Target, but Missing the Point” in Regulatory Impact Assessments: Does Bureaucratization Lead to Better RIAs ?
Open Access
- 12 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Regulation & Governance
- Vol. 21 (1)
Abstract
The extent to which Regulatory Impact Assessments (RIAs) conform to the “ideal” rational decision‐making model depends on factors such as political appropriation and the capacity of regulatory bodies. However, despite RIAs being embedded in bureaucratic settings, little research examines how the degree of formalization of RIA implementation affects their quality. In many contexts, RIAs are implemented within decision‐making environments characterized by bureaucratization, where discretion is constrained by legalism, formal boundaries, and standardized processes. This study investigates how bureaucratization influences RIA quality and whether regulators socialized in more bureaucratized administrative cultures rely more heavily on standardized procedures than their peers, thereby affecting RIA quality. Drawing on evidence from Brazilian regulatory agencies that operate within a traditionally bureaucratized administrative system, we employ a mixed‐methods design that combines OLS regression analysis with qualitative interviews. Our findings show that lower bureaucratization, operationalized as the use of strategic guidance documents that convey essential concepts and outline decision‐making steps, is associated with higher‐quality RIAs. By contrast, higher bureaucratization, characterized by the adoption of overly standardized templates, diminishes impact assessment quality. In addition, regulatory boards composed primarily of public sector professionals tend to adopt these templates more frequently, further reinforcing lower quality RIAs. Overall, the study contributes to research on the determinants of RIA quality and demonstrates how excessive bureaucratization can displace the intended goals of policy instruments.Keywords
Funding Information
- Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (307110/2022‐2)
- Fundação Carlos Chagas Filho de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro (E‐26/200.885/2021)
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Consumer’s Guide to Regulatory Impact Analysis: Ten Tips for Being an Informed PolicymakerJournal of Benefit-Cost Analysis, 2017
- Regulatory Process, Regulatory Reform, and the Quality of Regulatory Impact AnalysisJournal of Benefit-Cost Analysis, 2016
- Regulatory impact assessment: a survey of selected developing and emerging economiesPublic Money & Management, 2015
- Preventing Regulatory Capture2013
- Comparing the content of regulatory impact assessments in the UK and the EUPublic Money & Management, 2013
- Narrating Impact Assessment in the European UnionEuropean Political Science, 2013
- Does regulatory impact assessment lead to better policy?Policy and Society, 2010
- A general approach to causal mediation analysis.Psychological Methods, 2010
- The production and use of knowledge in regulatory impact assessment – An empirical analysisForest Policy and Economics, 2009
- The Spatial Consequences of Bureaucratic DecisionmakingEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 1983