This study employed an advanced metascientific methodological framework to investigate the controversial hypothesis of anomalous psychophysical interactions – the speculative capacity of the mind to influence distant physical systems through anomalous (i.e., yet-unidentified) mechanisms. The methodological framework integrated preregistration, the Advanced Meta-Experimental Protocol (AMP) counterfactual experimentation framework, statistical simulations, and self-replication strategies – all designed to minimize questionable research practices, rule out systematic errors, and assess replicability, thereby reducing the risk of false discoveries. A total of 390 participant sessions tested whether evidence could be observed for an ability of humans to influence a distant random number generator while observing real-time feedback. First, four preregistered experiments of 60 sessions were conducted, each testing a different outcome variable. Three of these variables comprised innovative designs that were developed in order to create optimal conditions for the observation of the hypothesized anomalous interactions under the assumption that the statistical parameter of bit equivalence must be conserved. Despite this effort to increase the chances of observing positive findings, none of the four experiments produced results that would justify rejecting the null hypothesis at the preregistered criteria for statistical significance (p ≤ 5%). A post-hoc exploratory analysis identified a variable showing a large deviation from mean chance expectancy in Experiment 3. The hypothesis that humans could exert anomalous influence on this variable was subsequently tested in a preregistered confirmatory follow-up study involving 150 sessions, which failed to replicate the initial exploratory finding. Overall, none of the experimental setups provided evidence supporting the hypothesis of anomalous psychophysical interactions. The study highlights the importance of preregistration, confirmatory testing of hypotheses derived from exploratory analyses, use of counterfactual control conditions, and methodological transparency. Beyond its empirical findings, the present work provides a comprehensive experimental suite, incorporating open-source hardware and software components, to facilitate independent replication and extensions. In addition, the methodological framework may be adapted to other domains of anomalies research employing innovative analytical paradigms.