JMJorge Moll

Jorge Moll

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Jorge Moll has a total of 388 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Making sense of the extraordinary – An investigation of the content and prevalence of appraisals of nonordinary experiences

    by Pedro Fortes, Luiza Tavares, Gustavo Granjeiro, Giovanna Bortolini, Everton Maraldi, Tiago Bortolini, Larissa Hartle, Maria Lima, Maria Laport, Jorge Moll, et al.

    Individuals around the world report nonordinary experiences that stand out to them compared to their day-to-day or ordinary experiences. Yet, they can be appraised in very different ways, resulting in wellbeing and personal growth, or in marginalization and mental health problems. One challenge is that there are relatively few systematic efforts to explore possible appraisal processes and the overall contextual features of these experiences. In study 1, we report a validation and extension of a previously designed set of appraisal and contextual questions to the Inventory of Nonordinary Experiences, with a sample of Brazilian participants (N = 160). The study successfully validated all original appraisal categories with minor modifications and added nine new context and appraisal categories. In study 2, we conducted a prevalence study by administering these questions in a general population sample (N = 5,117) in which individuals reported on one of 38 nonordinary experiences. Most contextual features and appraisals followed a unimodal distribution approximating a normal distribution. This suggests that nonordinary experiences, however heterogeneous they may be, appear to be interpreted within the same set of beliefs and appraisals, in addition to sharing similar temporal characteristics. Furthermore, although 20% of participants reported an immediate negative impact and 25% reported some degree of suffering or discomfort from experiences, 51% evaluated experiences as promoting overall positive long-term life effects. These findings highlight the potential of human resilience and the complex role of nonordinary experiences vis-a-vis protective factors in promoting health. Our results provide new insights into consciousness states and their mental health and wellbeing implications.


  • Mapping relationships of nonordinary experiences and mental health: A network analysis in a representative Brazilian sample.

    by Larissa Hartle, Maria Cristina Monteiro de Barros, Tiago Bortolini, Ronald Fischer, Jorge Moll, Arão Belitardo de Oliveira, Giancarlo Lucchetti, Mario Peres


  • Open Access

    Investigating the Claim of Anomalous Psychophysical Interactions Using a Rigorous Metascientific Framework

    by Gabriel Guerrer, Jan Walleczek, Nikolaus von Stillfried, Soraya Kffuri, Jorge Moll

    This study employed an advanced metascientific methodological framework to investigate the controversial hypothesis of anomalous psychophysical interactions – the speculative capacity of the mind to influence distant physical systems through anomalous (i.e., yet-unidentified) mechanisms. The methodological framework integrated preregistration, the Advanced Meta-Experimental Protocol (AMP) counterfactual experimentation framework, statistical simulations, and self-replication strategies – all designed to minimize questionable research practices, rule out systematic errors, and assess replicability, thereby reducing the risk of false discoveries. A total of 390 participant sessions tested whether evidence could be observed for an ability of humans to influence a distant random number generator while observing real-time feedback. First, four preregistered experiments of 60 sessions were conducted, each testing a different outcome variable. Three of these variables comprised innovative designs that were developed in order to create optimal conditions for the observation of the hypothesized anomalous interactions under the assumption that the statistical parameter of bit equivalence must be conserved. Despite this effort to increase the chances of observing positive findings, none of the four experiments produced results that would justify rejecting the null hypothesis at the preregistered criteria for statistical significance (p ≤ 5%). A post-hoc exploratory analysis identified a variable showing a large deviation from mean chance expectancy in Experiment 3. The hypothesis that humans could exert anomalous influence on this variable was subsequently tested in a preregistered confirmatory follow-up study involving 150 sessions, which failed to replicate the initial exploratory finding. Overall, none of the experimental setups provided evidence supporting the hypothesis of anomalous psychophysical interactions. The study highlights the importance of preregistration, confirmatory testing of hypotheses derived from exploratory analyses, use of counterfactual control conditions, and methodological transparency. Beyond its empirical findings, the present work provides a comprehensive experimental suite, incorporating open-source hardware and software components, to facilitate independent replication and extensions. In addition, the methodological framework may be adapted to other domains of anomalies research employing innovative analytical paradigms.

  • Open Access

    Mapping the Content Landscape of Self-transcendent Emotional Experiences with Thematic Analysis and Hierarchical Clustering

    by Tiago Bortolini, Maria Clara Laport, Giovanna Novaes Bortolini, Clarissa Alves de Sá, Ronald Fischer, Jorge Moll

    Self-transcendent emotions (STEs), including positive and threatening awe, compassion, admiration, elevation, gratitude, and love, expand one’s focus beyond the self and foster a sense of connection with something larger (e.g., people, nature, a higher power). Questions remain about the content structure that differentiates or unifies these emotions. We conducted four studies in Brazil, analyzing 1,683 narratives from the general population to clarify the nature and range of STEs in this underrepresented context. Study 1 developed and validated items measuring these emotions in Brazilian Portuguese, particularly critical for awe, as it lacks a direct translation. In Study 2, a bottom-up, qualitative template analysis from participants’ narratives yielded an initial coding template with 24 themes. Study 3 refined this template through qualitative coding, producing a final set of 34 unique themes. The theme of ‘connection with living forms’ emerged consistently across all STE narratives. Self-reported valence classifications indicated that several STEs’ experiences were ambivalent. In Study 4, a thematic hierarchical analysis revealed a robust link between positive and threatening awe, suggesting that these two variants share thematic elements compared to other STEs. Our qualitative narrative approach highlights STE’s thematical diversity and ambivalent valence, indicating that STEs do not form a homogeneous emotion category. Instead, our findings suggest that STEs are loosely connected to emotional reactions that share transcendental properties and are linked to cultural and social identities, but are likely driven by distinct affective processes.


  • Open Access

    Self-blame-selective social conceptual overgeneralisation and vulnerability to depression

    by Diede Fennema, Andrew J. Lawrence, Catherine A. Spilling, Jorge Moll, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, Roland Zahn

  • Open Access

    Mapping the Content Landscape of Self-Transcendent Emotional Experiences Using a Mixed-Method Approach

    by Tiago Bortolini, Maria Clara Laport, Giovanna Novaes Bortolini, Clarissa Alves de Sá, Ronald Fischer, Jorge Moll

    Self-transcendent emotions (STEs), including positive and threatening awe, compassion, admiration, elevation, gratitude, and love, expand one's focus beyond the self and foster a sense of connection with something larger (e.g., people, nature, a higher power). Despite growing interest, questions remain about the content structure that differentiates or unifies these emotions. We conducted four studies in Brazil, analyzing 1,683 narratives from the general population to clarify the nature and range of STEs in this underrepresented context. Study 1 developed and validated items measuring these emotions in Brazilian Portuguese, particularly critical for awe, as it lacks a direct translation. In Study 2, a bottom-up, qualitative template analysis from participants' narratives yielded an initial coding template with 24 themes. Study 3 refined this template through qualitative coding, producing a final set of 34 unique themes. The theme of 'connection with living forms' emerged consistently across all STE narratives. Self-report valence indicated that several STEs' experiences were ambivalent. In Study 4, a thematic hierarchical analysis revealed a robust link between positive and threatening awe, suggesting that these two variants share distinctive thematic elements compared to other STEs. Our qualitative narrative approach highlights STE's thematical diversity and ambivalent valence, indicating that STEs do not form a homogeneous emotion category. Instead, our findings suggest that STEs are loosely connected to emotional reactions that share transcendental properties and are linked to cultural and social identities, but are likely driven by distinct affective processes.

  • Open Access

    The paradox of the conscious “now” in the block universe: the multitrack consciousness conjecture

    by Jorge Moll

    This essay examines the important inconsistency between the relativistic block universe view of spacetime and subjective conscious experience, particularly the paradox of the privileged now moment in the context of a timeless reality. Addressing two postulates—that we live in a four-dimensional block universe where all moments are embedded within spacetime, and that conscious experience of the present moment is real—in this essay, the multitrack consciousness conjecture (MCC) is advanced as a solution for this paradox. This conjecture suggests the existence of multiple identical instances of our conscious selves in time, each one only being capable of experiencing a single moving now. The implications of the MCC for self-identity, emotion, memory, and shared experiences are discussed within the block universe framework and in more heterodox physical scenarios. The MCC offers a new perspective on the relations among the subjective nature of time, consciousness and the structure of events in spacetime.

  • Open Access

    Metascientific replication project with the advanced meta-experimental protocol of the transparent psi project procedures for testing the precognitive effect claimed by Bem

    by Jan Walleczek, Nikolaus von Stillfried, Stefan Schmidt, Marc Wittmann, Karolina A. Kirmse, Jorge Moll, Zoltan Kekecs

    This metascientific project studied the replicability of Bem Experiment 1, which had claimed a precognitive effect, i.e., the ability to successfully guess the outcome of future random events (Bem. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2011;100: 407-25). The use of advanced methodologies—based on the advanced meta-experimental protocol (AMP) and transparent psi project (TPP) procedures—reduced the risk of false discoveries as a function of (i) confirmation bias, (ii) non-transparency, and (iii) intrinsic measurement bias. The combined AMP-TPP test strategy performed three replication studies with a total of 26,483 participants resulting in N = 420,472 critical trials. Study 1 failed to replicate the precognitive effect. An exploratory analysis of Study 1 suggested an effect in the opposite direction than was originally predicted (49.48% ± 0.26 SE; N = 37,836). Study 2 confirmed this exploratory result using a high-powered replication design (49.65% ± 0.14 SE; p = 0.013; N = 127,000). Study 3 was unable to replicate the result from Study 2 (50.07% ± 0.11 SE; p = 0.496; N = 217,800). The result of Study 2 represents a rare example in psi research of the successful replication of an exploratory result using a confirmatory protocol. The source of the one-time confirmed anomalous result in Study 2 remains to be identified. This result presents either (i) a psi-derived anomaly that defies known physical laws, or (ii) a method-derived anomaly, e.g., a false-positive statistical finding. Using conventional standards, based on the lack of replicability in Study 3 and absence of an accepted scientific theory, the second scenario appears more plausible. This AMP-TPP metascientific project demonstrated the use of advanced controls for assessing the reliability of the employed scientific process. This project shows how rigor-enhancing test strategies can improve the reliability, not only of psi research, but any type of weak-effects experiments, including in psychology.

  • Open Access

    Making sense of the extraordinary – An exploration of the content and prevalence of appraisals of nonordinary experiences

    by Pedro Fortes, Luiza Tavares, Gustavo Fernandes Granjeiro, Giovanna Novaes Bortolini, Tiago Bortolini, Everton de Oliveira Maraldi, Larissa Hartle, Maria Vitoria de Lima Varejão, Maria Clara Laport, Jorge Moll, et al.

    Individuals around the world report nonordinary experiences that stand out to them compared to their day-to-day or ordinary experiences. Yet, they can be appraised in very different ways, resulting in wellbeing and personal growth or in marginalization and mental health problems. One challenge is that there are relatively few systematic efforts to explore possible appraisals and the overall contexts in which these experiences take place. We report a validation and extension of a previously designed set of follow-up and appraisal questions to the Inventory of Nonordinary Experiences, with a sample of Brazilian participants (N = 160). After validation, we administered these follow-up questions and appraisals in a general population sample (N = 5,117) in which individuals reported on one of 38 nonordinary experiences. Overall, the patterns suggest that individual response options are normally distributed, suggesting that there are several shared interpretations across a wide range of diverse experiences in the general population. Our results provide new insights into consciousness states and their mental health and wellbeing implications.

  • Open Access

    The Phenomenology of Non-Ordinary Experiences during Spiritualist Séances

    by Everton de Oliveira Maraldi, Ricardo de Oliveira Souza, Juliana Almeida, Ronald Fischer, Maria Eduarda Ismerio Moreira de Oliveira, Vitor de Oliveira Moura da Silva, Luiz Augusto de Queiroz, Tiago Bortolini, Jorge Moll

    Non-Ordinary experiences (NOEs), such as feelings of unity with God, hearing voices, and sensing the presence of deceased persons, are prevalent in the general population. They may be life-transforming but are also associated with pathological conditions such as psychosis and dissociation. However, little is known about how cultural appraisals and religious practices shape their phenomenology and psychological impact in non-clinical populations. For the most part, their socio-cognitive and emotional features remain unexplored. The purpose of this study was threefold. Firstly, to investigate the phenomenological characteristics and types of NOEs reported by self-defined spirit mediums from a spiritualist home circle in the city of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Secondly, to explore the role of social context in interpreting and shaping NOEs. Finally, to gain a better understanding of the phenomenological similarities and distinctions of experiences reported in spiritualist contexts with psychopathological constructs such as dissociative and psychotic symptoms. The study used a mixed-methods approach, combining ethnographic observations of spiritualist séances, thematic content analysis of reports of séance-related NOEs, and standardized scales assessing dissociation, absorption, psychotic symptoms, symptoms of common mental disorders, and satisfaction with life. We analyzed a total of 151 independent reports of NOEs provided by a group of mediumship practitioners participating in regular séances over a period of one year and five months. The reports tapped a variety of experiences including intense emotional states (e.g., happiness, gratitude), alterations in consciousness (e.g., feelings of spacing out), spontaneous mental imagery (e.g., visions of the spiritual world), sensory-perceptual experiences (e.g., hearing voices or other unusual sounds), somatic manifestations (e.g., body tremors), and unusual experiences involving the séance table (e.g., vibrations). The experiences reported were episodic, controllable, and restricted to the séances. Overall, they were described as pleasant or innocuous. Mediums generally reported perceiving their lives as satisfying and meaningful and scored similarly to the general population on items indicative of common mental disorders. Given their cultural impact and predominantly positive effects, these experiences bear implications for differential diagnosis, and the role of cultural and religious factors in mental health, wellbeing, and cognition. The spiritualist séance provide a natural environment for observational and experimental studies of intentionally induced non-ordinary states of consciousness.Keywords: non-ordinary experiences, dissociative experiences, psychotic experiences, psychosis continuum, spirit mediumship, religious rituals, spirituality