Transaction Fee Mechanisms and User Welfare in Permissionless Blockchains
- 24 July 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 35 (3) , 921-938
Abstract
A transaction fee is fundamental in maintaining the stability and decentralization of a permissionless blockchain, the infrastructure underlying major cryptocurrency networks such as Ethereum and Bitcoin. This fee, set and paid by users when initiating each transaction, aggregates to over $24 million daily on Ethereum, imposing a nontrivial barrier to wider adoption. What is worse is that it is disproportionately borne by small users. Like Bitcoin, Ethereum started with a name-your-own-price style fee mechanism. Under this Legacy mechanism, we demonstrate that, surprisingly, only three-quarters of the transaction fee is necessary for users to attain the service quality they receive; the remaining one-quarter thus constitutes welfare loss. In August 2021, Ethereum implemented a fee mechanism change. Together, the Legacy methods and the new scheme, which we call Cap-Tip, describe the two most widely used fee mechanisms in all major permissionless blockchains. We explain the innovations embedded in the Cap-Tip mechanism through the lens of information quality and task decomposition. Collecting over 123 million transactions covering the change period, we estimate the causal impact of Cap-Tip on welfare improvement using a doubly robust difference-in-difference estimator that accommodates heterogeneity across timing of and exposure after adoption. The result is an astounding 80% reduction in welfare loss, achieved by users only 6 days after adoption. Interestingly, we also find that adoption benefits small users more than large ones, alleviating fee disparity and improving fairness. We theorize this difference through user experience and the overconfidence bias. Our study offers a novel operational perspective to unpack how the arguably most significant fee mechanism change in the blockchain space affects user welfare.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Success and Failure of Blockchain Technology Providers: Founders' Power, Beyond‐Blockchain Exploration and Centralized Decision‐MakingJournal of Operations Management, 2025
- Transition from plan to market: Imperfect regulations in the electricity sector of ChinaJournal of Comparative Economics, 2024
- Need for speed, but how much does it cost? Unpacking the fee‐speed relationship in Bitcoin transactionsJournal of Operations Management, 2022
- Task management in decentralized autonomous organizationJournal of Operations Management, 2022
- Difference-in-Differences with multiple time periodsJournal of Econometrics, 2021
- Survey of security supervision on blockchain from the perspective of technologyJournal of Information Security and Applications, 2021
- Empirical Analyses of Nonlinear Effects of Reserve Prices on Ending Prices in Online AuctionsJournal of Interactive Marketing, 2021
- An empirical study of the behavior of patients who leave the emergency department without being seenJournal of Operations Management, 2019
- Algorithm appreciation: People prefer algorithmic to human judgmentOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2019
- Reserve price and competing bids: Reference points for product evaluations in online auctions?Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 2015