Extending science instruction beyond the CER: Use of critical questions in the argumentation of middle school science students
- 11 May 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Science Education
- Vol. 108 (5) , 1420-1447
Abstract
Critiquing arguments is important for K‐12 science students to learn but not emphasized by the predominant claim‐evidence‐reasoning (CER) argumentation model. Drawing on the work of Yu and Zenker (2020), and Dove and Nussbaum (2018), we developed a tool for supplementing CER with critical questions (CQs) from philosophy that cover most, if not all, the logical dimensions of argument critique. Six middle school science teachers designed lessons involving argumentation, including the use of CQs. We assessed the effects on student self‐efficacy for engaging in argument critique, teacher self‐efficacy for using argument pedagogy, and teachers’ perceptions of the value of CQs. Qualitative data included teacher interviews, lesson transcripts, and student work samples. Quantitative data included surveys of student self‐efficacy administered at the beginning and end of the school year. There was evidence suggesting an increase over time in students’ confidence for engaging in argument critique and teachers’ confidence with argument pedagogy. However, only four of the six teachers were confident and skilled enough to include CQs in their lessons. Those who did use CQs tended to perceive them as providing a helpful structure for critique, prompts for deeper thinking, and a tool for fostering critical classroom norms. Discussion of CQs may have benefitted students’ writing by promoting peer critique and encouragement to elaborate. Overall, CQs afford students with a framework for judging argument strength. Scientific argumentation involving CQs provides a more contemporary philosophical basis for scientific argumentation than CER or the Toulmin model as it emphasizes the critical and dialogic nature of science.Keywords
This publication has 74 references indexed in Scilit:
- Key challenges and future directions for educational research on scientific argumentationJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2017
- Understanding how teachers guide evidence construction conversationsScience Education, 2017
- The development and validation of a learning progression for argumentation in scienceJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2016
- Educational Implications of Choosing “Practice” to Describe Science in the Next Generation Science StandardsScience Education, 2015
- Writing to Learn by Learning to Write During the School Science Laboratory: Helping Middle and High School Students Develop Argumentative Writing Skills as They Learn Core IdeasScience Education, 2013
- Science teachers and scientific argumentation: Trends in views and practiceJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2012
- Learners' epistemic criteria for good scientific modelsJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2011
- A learning progression for scientific argumentation: Understanding student work and designing supportive instructional contextsScience Education, 2010
- TAPping into argumentation: Developments in the application of Toulmin's Argument Pattern for studying science discourseScience Education, 2004
- Small-group discussion in physics: Peer interaction modes in pairs and foursJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1996