Expert Perceptions of the Ecological Impacts of Road Construction in Natural Ecosystems: A Cross-Disciplinary Comparison
Open Access
Abstract
Expert assessments of the ecological impacts of road construction in natural ecosystems were examined through a cross-disciplinary comparative perspective. Data were collected from experts in civil engineering, urban and regional planning, forest engineering, and landscape architecture. Responses to the Ecological Impacts of Road Construction in Natural Ecosystems (EIRCNE) scale were analyzed using exploratory factor analysis and comparative statistical tests. Five hypotheses (H1–H5) were developed to examine disciplinary differences in expert evaluations. Results indicated broad agreement on the overall ecological impacts of road construction, although discipline-specific differences emerged in perceptions of direct ecological damage and construction priorities. Factor analysis confirmed a multidimensional structure of expert assessments (KMO = 0.810; χ2 = 1665.219; df = 435; p < 0.001). Hypotheses concerning direct ecological damage (H2) and construction priorities (H5) were supported, whereas no significant disciplinary differences were detected for indirect effects or managerial processes (H3 and H4). These findings suggest that evaluating road planning and construction solely from a technical perspective may overlook important ecological dimensions. The study provides empirical evidence from Türkiye regarding how experts from different professional disciplines perceive and prioritize the ecological impacts of road construction and highlights the importance of incorporating diverse disciplinary perspectives into environmental decision-making processes.Keywords
This publication has 120 references indexed in Scilit:
- Land Degradation and Its Impacts on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services2023
- Mapping potential effects of proposed roads on migratory connectivity for a highly mobile herbivore using circuit theoryEcological Applications, 2020
- Eco-system Services and Integrated Urban Planning. A Multi-criteria Assessment Framework for Ecosystem Urban Forestry Projects2019
- The impact of road disturbance on vegetation and soil properties in a beech stand, Hyrcanian forestEuropean Journal of Forest Research, 2018
- A behavior‐based framework for assessing barrier effects to wildlife from vehicle traffic volumeEcosphere, 2016
- Hybrid MCDA Methods to Integrate Multiple Ecosystem Services in Forest Management Planning: A Critical ReviewEnvironmental Management, 2015
- The Ecological Effects of Linear Infrastructure and Traffic2015
- Landforms of High Mountains2015
- Towards Sustainable Livelihoods and Ecosystems in Mountain Regions2014
- Road ecology: Science and solutions by Richard T. T. Forman, Daniel Sperling, John A. Bissonette, Anthony P. Clevenger, Carol D. Cutshall, Virginia H. Dale, Lenore Fahrig, Robert France, Charles R. Goldman, Kevin Heanue, Julia A. Jones, Frederick J. Swanson, Thomas Turrentine, and Thomas C. Winter Island Press Covelo, WA, and London, UK (2002) 481 pages ISBN 1‐55963‐932‐6 (cloth) U.S. List Price: $55.00 ISBN 1‐55963‐933‐4 (paper) U.S. List Price: $27.50Environmental Progress, 2003