Principal–Agent or Principal–Steward: How Ministry–Agency Relations Condition the Impact of Performance Management in the Steering of Government Agencies
Open Access
- 24 March 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Public Performance & Management Review
- Vol. 43 (5) , 1053-1077
Abstract
Using agency and stewardship theories, this article investigates conditions that affect the impact of performance management in the ministerial steering of agencies. Agency theory assumes that agencies act opportunistically, leading to low trust between the ministry and the agency. Conversely, stewardship theory assumes that agencies act trustworthily. Arguably, however, in the steering of agencies, the impact of performance management depends on performance management practices and the type of ministry–agency relation. The effect of performance contract design and a top-down or bottom-up approach to performance management on the impact of performance management is analyzed in the context of whether the ministry–agency relation tends toward the principal–agent or principal–steward type. The data were obtained from a survey of bureaucrats employed in government agencies in Norway and a systematic analysis of official policy documents. The results show that a bottom-up approach increases the impact of performance management in principal–steward relations but not in principal–agent relations. Performance contract design has no effect on the impact of performance management, irrespective of relationship characteristics.Keywords
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- What is the Effect of Performance Measurement on Perceived Accountability Effectiveness in State and Local Government Contracts?Public Performance & Management Review, 2011
- Do Relationships Matter?Public Performance & Management Review, 2010
- Through A Glass, DarklyPublic Performance & Management Review, 2009
- Agency Theory and Beyond: Contracted Providers' Motivations to Properly Use Service Monitoring ToolsJournal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 2008
- The Evolution of Corporate Governance: power redistribution brings boards to lifeCorporate Governance: An International Review, 2007
- Trust and contract completeness in the public sectorLocal Government Studies, 2007
- Performance Management in Practice: A Comparative Study of Executive AgenciesJournal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 2005
- Ensuring Accountability in Human Services ContractingThe American Review of Public Administration, 2002
- Exploring Contracts as Reinvented Institutions in the Danish Public SectorPublic Administration, 2000
- Measurement and Meaningful ManagementPublic Productivity & Management Review, 1993