Solving the Two-Stage Design Interest Paradox Between Chinese EPC Project Owners and General Contractors: A Case Study
Open Access
- 2 September 2025
- Vol. 15 (17) , 3162
Abstract
In recent years, China has vigorously promoted the EPC mode in the construction industry. However, under the weak trust environment of China’s construction industry, both owners and general contractors are involved in the design stage of EPC projects. Owing to conflicting interests in the design stage, there is a two-stage design interest paradox between the owners and general contractors of Chinese EPC projects, and this causes significant difficulties and challenges for project implementation. To resolve this paradox, this study proposes the “DART-PDCA” design management model by integrating value co-creation theory with the PDCA cycle. Applied to the Yuzhou High-speed Rail Station Square and Related Infrastructure PPP Project and the extended case, the model demonstrates how it resolves the paradox by (1) establishing structured dialogue platforms for aligning evolving design intentions, (2) enhancing information access and transparency through agreed protocols, and (3) facilitating dynamic risk assessment and allocation mechanisms. The results confirm that (1) the two-stage design interest paradox negatively impacts design management quality in China’s low-trust environment; and (2) the “DART-PDCA” design management model effectively resolves this paradox, leading to demonstrable improvements in design management quality, efficiency, and stakeholder alignment. This research forges novel interdisciplinary linkages among owner–general contractor relationships, design management, and EPC projects, providing critical insights into managing multi-organizational dynamics in complex EPC project environments.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Social Science Fund of China (21BGL029)
This publication has 75 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing the relevance of different proximity dimensions for knowledge exchange and (co-)creation in sustainability-oriented innovation networksSustainability Science, 2024
- Value co‐creation on technology‐enabled platforms for business model responsiveness and position enhancement in global value chainsStrategic Change, 2022
- Benefits management in university-industry collaboration programsInternational Journal of Project Management, 2021
- Extending the luxury experience to social media – User-Generated Content co-creation in a branded eventJournal of Business Research, 2020
- How to allocate energy-saving benefit for guaranteed savings EPC projects? A case of ChinaEnergy, 2020
- The post-normal politics and science of wind power planning: Evidence from a Danish near-shore wind farm tenderEnergy Research & Social Science, 2019
- Capturing the broader picture of value co-creation managementEuropean Management Journal, 2019
- Four reference models for transparency requirements in information systemsRequirements Engineering, 2017
- Maximizing Knowledge Work Productivity: A Time Constrained and Activity Visualized PDCA CycleKnowledge and Process Management, 2012
- Co-creation experiences: The next practice in value creationJournal of Interactive Marketing, 2004