What to assess in circular buildings: key performance indicators for circular transformation
Open Access
- 11 March 2026
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Smart and Sustainable Built Environment
- p. 1-23
Abstract
Purpose: This study addresses the critical gap in evaluating building circularity by developing a comprehensive framework of key performance indicators (KPIs). While circular economy (CE) principles are increasingly emphasized in building design, their adoption is hindered by the absence of standardized and prioritized KPIs across the building lifecycle. Design/methodology/approach: A two-stage research design was employed. First, a systematic meta-synthesis of literature identified micro-level KPIs. Second, industry and academic experts validated and ranked them using a two-round fuzzy Delphi method and fuzzy analytical hierarchy process. Findings: The study developed the Building Circularity KPI Framework (building circularity KPIs framework [BCKPIF]), comprising 52 KPIs across six domains: material, waste, energy, water, CO2 emissions and design. Findings highlight the need to incorporate overlooked circularity aspects such as energy, water, CO2 emissions and design. BCKPIF shows a clear KPI prioritization: disassembly, refusing unnecessary new construction and material durability ranked highest overall. It also reveals prioritizations across different categories, reflecting preferred CE strategies for each category – for instance, reuse received the greatest weight for the material and waste categories. Research limitations/implications: This study focuses on technical and environmental dimensions of building circularity. Economic and social aspects are excluded to allow a more focused and measurable assessment of circularity in buildings as CE focuses more narrowly on resource efficiency, material loops and system innovation. Practical implications: Weighted KPIs guide practitioners in prioritizing interventions and selecting materials, technologies and design strategies. For policymakers, the results provide an evidence base for translating circular design strategies, such as reuse, modularity and deconstruction into regulatory benchmarks, procurement requirements and incentive mechanisms. The framework also supports progress toward multiple sustainable development goals. Originality/value: This study advances the field by consolidating fragmented micro-level circularity KPIs into a comprehensive and weighted framework, integrating overlooked aspects such as energy, water and CO2 emissions alongside design strategies.Keywords
This publication has 71 references indexed in Scilit:
- From circularity to sustainability: Advancing the whole building circularity indicator with Life Cycle Assessment (WBCI-LCA)Building and Environment, 2024
- Whole building circularity indicator: A circular economy assessment framework for promoting circularity and sustainability in buildings and constructionBuilding and Environment, 2023
- Closing the loop through eco‐innovation by European firms: Circular economy for sustainable developmentBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2022
- A systemic review for measuring circular economy with multi-criteria methodsEnvironmental Science and Pollution Research, 2022
- Maximising the circular economy and sustainability outcomes: An end-of-life tyre recycling outlets selection modelInternational Journal of Production Economics, 2021
- Sustainable ecotourism indicators with fuzzy Delphi method – A Philippine perspectiveEcological Indicators, 2018
- FLEX 4.0, A Practical Instrument to Assess the Adaptive Capacity of BuildingsEnergy Procedia, 2016
- Direct and indirect energy use and carbon emissions in the production phase of buildings: An input–output analysisEnergy, 2007
- Applications of the extent analysis method on fuzzy AHPEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 1996
- Fuzzy hierarchical analysisFuzzy Sets and Systems, 1985