Follow the Leader: The European Commission, the European Court of Justice, and the EU’s Rule of Law Revolution
Preprint
- 21 February 2024
- preprint
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in APSA Preprints
Abstract
The autocratization of Hungary and Poland prompted a revolution in the European Court of Justice’s (ECJ) caselaw. The Court imposed novel obligations on member states to safeguard the rule of law (ROL) and expanded the legal bases for the EU to sanction governments. We ask: did the ECJ pioneer this ROL revolution or respond to an entrepreneurial European Commission acting as “guardian of the Treaties?” While supranationalist theories depict the Commission as a proactive agenda-setter, studies of the EU’s ROL crisis argue that the Commission dragged its feet or only recently seized the reins of leadership. Deploying a new theory of judicial innovation and agenda-setting on an original dataset of all ROL cases adjudicated by the ECJ, we demonstrate that the Commission has been an inconsistent and often indifferent agenda-setter. Besides several proactive interventions during the Juncker Commission, the Court’s rulings prompted the Commission to act more than the reverse.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Norges Forskningsråd (325707)
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- How backsliding governments keep the European Union hospitable for autocracy: Evidence from intergovernmental negotiationsThe Review of International Organizations, 2023
- The CJEU Database Platform: Decisions and Decision-MakersJournal of Law and Courts, 2023
- Enchantment and critical distance in EU legal scholarship: what role for institutional lawyers?European Law Open, 2022
- The Politics of Legal Expertise in EU Policy-Making2021
- Protecting the Rule of Law in the EU Legal Order: A Constitutional Role for the Court of JusticeEuropean Constitutional Law Review, 2020
- Judicial serendipity: how Portuguese judges came to the rescue of the Polish judiciaryEuropean Constitutional Law Review, 2018
- The European Court of Justice, State Noncompliance, and the Politics of OverrideAmerican Political Science Review, 2012
- A Postfunctionalist Theory of European Integration: From Permissive Consensus to Constraining DissensusBritish Journal of Political Science, 2009
- The European Commission and the Integration of Europe2002
- Europe Before the Court: A Political Theory of Legal IntegrationInternational Organization, 1993